Women journalists on the front line – starting in the 19th century
Comment and summary from The Guardian, April 16, 2011.
As somebody who grew up wanting nothing more than to be Kate Adie (a BBC journalist who reported from war zones around the world), I was fascinated by this article.
It details the rise of female journalists from people regarded as being “as far removed organically from [male journalists] as a dog from a cat” (thanks Arnold Bennett) to full participants in world-wide war reporting.
Female journalists first turned their backs on domestic matters (the only things they were considered able to cover) in significant numbers during the second world war, where their presence alone merited several sensational news stories.
By the end of that war, there were 127 accredited women war correspondents from America alone, and the number of female frontline journalists has been increasing rapidly ever since.
The article lists notable early female war reporters such as Clare Hollingworth (who broke the story – to the British government as well as to her readers – of Germany’s invasion of Poland, and reported for The Guardian and the Daily Telegraph from Palestine, Algeria and China), Martha Gellhorn, whose many wars included Spain, the second world war, the Vietnam war and conflicts in Central America and Virginia Cowles, who also covered Spain as well as the liberation of Paris and the Allied invasion of Germany.
But these formidable figures, and their valiant predecessors in the first world war, were not the earliest pioneers of the profession.
Several exceptional women had reported from some of the most harrowing battle zones of the 19th century, and their own stories were often as remarkable as any they covered.
Margaret Fuller became the first accredited woman foreign correspondent when she was commissioned by the New York Tribune to cover the Roman revolution in Italy in 1848.
In 1860, Jessie White, daughter of a Hampshire builder, went to Sicily to report on Garibaldi’s renewed campaign.
But, as journalists, let alone war correspondents, these women were a rarity. By 1880, census records showed that of 12,308 journalists working in the US, only 288 were women, and most of them were reporting on soft furnishings rather than hard news.
In 1897, Randolph Hearst’s New York Journal announced that it had appointed Cora Stewart Taylor as “the first woman war correspondent” – a claim with which Fuller and White could have taken issue.
Taylor was sent to cover the Greco-Turkish war. She wrote: “I am a strange woman to whom fear of many kinds is unknown. I could dare, or do, some strange things without flinching if I were driven.”
In 1898, Anna N. Benjamin, a young reporter for Leslie’s Illustrated News (based in New York), resolved to cover the invasion of Cuba by American troops in the Spanish-American war.
She told a British fellow correspondent: “I know what you think. You think it ridiculous my being here, you are laughing at me wanting to go, that’s the worst of being a woman.
“But just let me tell you, I’m going through to Cuba and not all the old generals in the army are going to stop me.”
Benjamin got to the front, scooped her competitors, and the following year was sent to cover the Philippine insurrection, before travelling by Trans-Siberian railroad to report in Russia, Japan and China.
Women also covered the horror that was the first world war.
Mary Roberts Rinehart, a successful writer of mystery novels and later known as the “American Agatha Christie”, was among the first American reporters to reach the Belgian front in the first world war.
Elizabeth Cochrane, better known to her readers in America as the “stunt reporter” Nellie Bly, also travelled to Europe to report from the war’s eastern front.
Cochrane had built an international reputation as a campaigning journalist, specialising in undercover work which exposed injustice and changed policy on healthcare, housing and child labour.
For her most celebrated story, she feigned madness and was admitted to a New York insane asylum for 10 days, later writing about the harshness of conditions, abusive staff, and the fact that many inmates were sane but had been falsely incarcerated by relatives who wanted them out of the way.
In one dispatch from the front line she described the last hours of a mortally wounded Russian soldier, ending with an account of his last words,
“His words were a sound my ears shall never forget . . . “What does he say?” I cried, unable to stand it . . . “He is asking for his children,” was the low reply. The hollow black eyes turned again to search mine.
“I could not endure their question. I had no answer to give. “Could Emperors and Czars and Kings look on this torturing slaughter and ever sleep again?” I asked the doctor.
“They do not look,” he said gently.”
By 1930, US records show that the number of women journalists had risen to 12,000 – 24% of the total number of journalists. But the average female reporter’s beat was still the home front, and they were still subject to derision from their male colleagues.
Ishbel Ross, a Scottish-born journalist who had earned a reputation as New York City’s best female news reporter in the 1920s, wrote Ladies of the Press, a survey of early newspaperwomen.
The foreword to her book was written by her former editor at the Herald Tribune, Stanley Walker, and it was not encouraging to any young woman thinking of a career in the papers.
“A great many of the girls who have managed to get on newspaper payrolls have been slovenly, incompetent vixens, adept at office politics, show-offs of the worst sort, and inclined to take advantage of their male colleagues.
“They have protested that they wanted to do a man’s work, to be treated as men, but soon [sic] or later some situation would arise in which all these high-minded declarations of purpose were revealed as so much nonsense.”
Ross herself was described by Walker as an exception to the rule, but it seems amazing that she accepted his foreword.
At the time Ross’s book was published, Martha Gellhorn (a personal hero of mine), had already made her name in her native America with her book, The Trouble I’ve Seen, about American lives blighted by the Depression.
But Gellhorn, hungry for greater engagement, was convinced that Spain, where volunteer soldiers were flocking from around the world to join the fight again Franco’s fascist forces, was the crucible in which the future would be forged.
She arrived in Madrid in 1937, on assignment for Collier’s magazine, and used her powerful, pared-down prose to describe the impact of war on civilians as well as on the Republican soldiers.
She had no interest in what she later termed “the objectivity shit”. She was there to bear witness to injustice and suffering, she declared, and felt no need to “balance” the story with a view from the other side.
Clare Hollingworth had a more traditional, some might say masculine, approach to war reporting; outlining battle strategy, recording troop movements, detailing armaments, analysing political context and striving for impartiality.
The American journalist Virginia Cowles, one of Gellhorn’s colleagues in Spain, also aimed for “balance” in her stories.
In Spain, where Cowles picked her way through bombsites and trenches in exceptionally high heels, she herself became the subject of a news story when she was “kidnapped” by a Soviet divisional commander of the International Brigade.
For three days, over countless glasses of champagne, he instructed her in Marxist theory before finally letting her go.
In 1950 when the Korean war started, the US high command tried to ban female reporters.
Marguerite Higgins, fearless, clever and strikingly competitive, was Tokyo bureau chief of the Herald Tribune when the war broke out and she was one of the first reporters on the spot.
Army authorities warned her that there was a lack of lavatory facilities for women in the field, to which she replied that she was happy to use either side of the road.
But in the midst of the bloody battle for Taejon, she was ordered out of Korea by Lieutenant General Walton W Walker, Eighth Army Commander, who said: “This is just not the type of war where women ought to be running around the front lines.”
Eventually, after a personal appeal to General MacArthur, she returned to the front and went on to win a Pulitzer prize for her coverage of the war.
Korea was not Higgins’ first war. She had previously reported from Germany, where she witnessed the liberation of Dachau and Buchenwald and covered the blockade of Berlin.
Higgins was known for her beauty as well as her ravenous appetite for a scoop and it was (sadly but unsurprisingly) suggested that she was not afraid to use the former in pursuit of the latter.
But there was never any doubt about Higgins’ courage and commitment to her work. She wrote of the “human closeness and magnificence of character that danger sometimes provokes”.
These trail-blazing women helped pave the way for female reporters to step out of the narrow limits for which they were considered suitable.











