subscribe: Posts | Comments

What happens when women put their heads “below the line”?

11 comments

Jane Da Vall
Ex-Guardian reader

The takeover of the UK newspaper, thumb case Guardian online, by its implacable enemies is richly ironic.

That this most liberal of newspapers accepts the right of right-wing Daily Mail readers to occupy its site and heap scorn on everything it publishes is a good joke.

That it continues to allow it for five years is hilarious.  How amusing the knots that liberals tie themselves in, trying so hard to be fair.

Then I remember that the trouble which the Guardian has brought upon itself has real and destructive consequences for others, particularly women. Consequences which continue today, and are not funny at all.

I wrote here recently describing Comment is Free, the Guardian’s online forum, as a haven for misogynists, who have all but driven women from the site.

Chris Elliott, the Readers’ Editor, and his colleague in corrections and qualifications, Leslie Plommer, were good enough to meet me to discuss the concerns I had raised.  I was hoping I would learn how Comment is Free (CiF) came to be so destructively ironic.

I am a little wiser.  I know that the Guardian recognises a problem with a hostile group of men who besiege feminist articles.

Their aggression has been effective in driving women off the site and silencing them on the issues of the greatest importance concerning their basic rights and freedoms.

The editors know they are not doing enough to encourage women to stay and make themselves heard. However, they are less concerned by the abusive culture than some of their female readers. I had not fully appreciated the importance of ‘the line.’

Readers place reliance on what they read ‘above the line’. Accordingly, standards and ethics and an editorial policy apply above the line.

Below the line is comment, which is subject to nothing but the community standards.The Guardian does not think it influences readers much or is, in fact, misogynous. I heard again that women only perceive misogyny.

This is how the Guardian says “calm down, dear,” with a touch more subtlety than David Cameron. I don’t agree on either point.

I think 200 or 300 comments on a thread screaming of false rape claims or consent withdrawn with the next day’s remorse can be highly influential.

I think it influences the decision of the Crown Prosecution Service not to risk trial with the victim who had a drink.

It then goes on to influence the future life of the next victim of that rapist and the next and the next, in a manner they will never have contemplated.

They may not even be readers.  I think men who work so tirelessly on Comment is Free to see rapists go unpunished hate women.

The plan outlined by the CiF editor to drive the haters out was nonsense, I said, and would fail. They wanted to encourage women to stick it out, to battle the hostility and, in doing so, to change the culture.

This plan has been tried by successive editors for five years. It has achieved nothing at all. They could not say what account the editor had taken of this history of failure. Natalie Hanman was appointed editor less than a year ago but has been on the staff for some years.

We did not discuss the relevance of £30 to £40 million in advertising revenue earned last year from right-wing traffic volumes in excess of two million readers daily, readers who closely resemble Daily Mail readers and like the culture just as it is.

They told me that writers are being encouraged to engage more below the line. It is a good idea, but what is it expected to achieve?

The editors will not ban those among the commentors who will not engage, who are responsible for the culture. Nor will they close articles to comment.

They allow feminist debate to be stifled and feminist writers and readers to be abused simply because they are feminist.  They allow the threads of feminist articles to be dominated by demands to stop publishing feminist articles.

They will not contemplate such a move, the editorial policy governs above the line, so why publish the comment below the line? It achieves nothing and stifles all other debate.

They gave me examples of ‘action’ taken; Chris Elliott’s column on CiF asking ‘is CiF anti-women?’ for one. I disagreed. The column did not do anything. To talk to women he needs to go elsewhere, something he has not done at all as Readers’ Editor.

To change the culture they must first rid Comment is Free of those who will not change.  It is their core community. They have to start again.

They have to go where women are and bring them back to a new Comment is Free.  The new CiF must not tolerate any one voice dominating the community.

This means more subjective moderation. That is, if the Guardian actually wants something approaching free comment on Comment is Free.

  1. Pavlov's Cat says:

    Oh dear. Yet again we’re hearing the same old lines trotted out. Sexism is only a problem for women, so it’s women’s responsibility to sort it out. No, and no.

  2. Jane Da Vall says:

    They will not even let women sort it out. They continue with the policy that causes least trouble, which is to do nothing.

  3. Yet we know other papers that have the same problem have taken a principled approach to this issue as I understand it from Jane.

  4. Jane Da Vall says:

    The Ventura County Star had a similar problem to the Guardian with abusive comment but responded in a rather different way. The link to their statement is in the extract of my mail sent today to Reader’s Editor, Chris Elliott, copied below. Let us hope for a similar display of principle from the Guardian.

    “Dear Chris,

    ..Women on Comment is Free are scarcer than ever. Yesterday, there was:

    1 woman, and 38 men commenting on the front page of Harriet Harman’s article (http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2011/may/23/rape-ken-clarke-justice-police.

    The tenor of the comments was positive:1 negative: 38. My point, as before, is not to complain of criticism but to show you that women are not only not there, but their views are not being aired by the men who are there. Today there are :

    4 women and 37 men (Comments 46:4) on the front page of http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2011/may/24/women-in-power-gender-imbalance
    2 women and 31 men (Comments 46:4) on the front page of http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2011/may/23/saudi-women-driving-ban-rebellion

    There are men:

    a) Claiming that the hate posting is traditional Guardian reader opinion (well it is now)
    b) Publicizing false rape propaganda websites.
    c) Claiming that the justice system is at risk from rape prosecution powers
    d) Attacking the lone women commentors in groups, and
    e) Posting the familiar contempt for women.

    I understand that you don’t consider these comments to be sexist. Do you accept that they are contributing to the almost compete absence of women on CiF’s feminist pages? What about your online readers? Are your advertisers still reporting 63% of female readers of these pages?

    I was waiting for a response from you, I think, on the question of how five years of failure to attract women to CiF had been factored into the decision to continue the same strategy. Also, how the demographics are actually monitored and what work is being done to encourage women to comment in the forum. There are no CiF staff on the front comment pages of those articles above.

    What do you plan to do if and when there are no women at all? Will you continue to open articles on sexual assault for comment only by men hostile to sexual assault victims? Here is a newspaper, the mighty Ventura County Star (http://www.vcstar.com/news/2011/may/07/howry-cleaning-up-the-comment-cesspool/) who have taken the decision not to do that. There are victims reading the hatred that gets pumped out of CiF every day, not to mention a vast reading public that respect the name of the Guardian and that do not understand who these men are because you have given them anonymity. I can only ask you again to take action. Remove the architects of the hate culture or take away their platform.
    …

    Best Regards
    Jane Da Vall”

  5. You are doing good work, Jane, by continuing to hold the CiF eds to account over this. Thanks.

    What I did want to stress, which I’m sure you’re aware of, is that it’s not just a matter of outsiders from the Mail and Times infiltrating ‘our’ internet spaces, but a problem within the left itself. On other liberal news sites, like Liberal Conspiracy and New Statesman, female writers and commenters get shouted down, belittled and objectified by other commenters who express lefty sentiments in the rest of their posts. All I can guess is that some liberal men who feel pressured to toe the feminist line in public feel less inhibited under the anonymity of the internet. You only have to read the comments on anything by Laurie Penny to see this. Sample: ‘I’m a proper Marxist, you’re a silly woman, I’ll give you something to stop you looking so glum and serious, hur hur hur’.

    My most recent experience of this – nothing compared to what commenters get on threads about rape, sexual assault and the rest – was after I posted a comment (maybe on LC?) on a piece about ‘real’ women, making something like the fairly standard point that the equation of curvy with ‘real’ excludes lots of (most?) women from the definition of female. Perhaps inevitably, a bunch of male commenters decided that the most pressing issue was the size of my tits, which they then proceeded to debate. Great, thanks guys, really added to the level of conversation.

    • Jane Da Vall says:

      Nice. A lot of grievance and frustration is being worked out on complete strangers thanks to online anonymity.

      I do see the problem on the left, yes. Feminism is such a flash point because it unites men on the left and right on CiF. There is the anti-identity politics of the class warriors, perhaps the biggest group on CiF, and the Labour Party and unions have long histories of betraying and belittling women, I know. The netroots conference earlier this year looked like more of the same.

      Women and feminism don’t have a section of male support anywhere on the CiF political spectrum. There are few women and even fewer pro-feminist men. That’s not to say there isn’t male support out there, they just get targeted and go elsewhere. You can see it all the time, unless you are on the staff, who apparently can’t.

  6. Yonmei says:

    I had a guest blog published at Guardian Edinburgh not long ago. I would never have considered sending an equivalent piece to Comment Is Free, as it says in the guidelines that you are required to interact with the commenters, and I cannot imagine anything worse than having to interact with the screaming misogynistic homophobic bigots that make reading CiF threads unpleasant and boring. I got a small number of comments at Guardian Edinburgh, all relevant, none hostile.

    Guardian Edinburgh is to be discontinued next week, though.

    • Jane Da Vall says:

      Yonmei,

      It is ironic that the one policy the Guardian has introduced to address the culture is to encourage writers to engage with commentors below the line. All it has done is discourage writers above the line.

      That they would think this one change could have an impact on the culture demonstrates how fundamentally they misunderstand the problem, in its nature and scale, and how their response is to make concessions to the mob, by giving them writers to insult in person or publicizing their cause by commissioning and publishing men’s rights advocates.

      They seem to think that the abuse is in some way connected to the writer. It isn’t, it is only about what the commentor wants. They want to stop feminist debate on Comment is Free and that’s what they have dome. If they could get above the line they would remove it from there too, no matter who is writing, replace it with their ‘equality feminism’. The hijacking of language is chilling.

  7. Karen Whiteley says:

    That link to the Ventura County Star just shows that it’s entirely possible to put a stop to CiF behaviour, just by saying, actually, we’re just not having it, take your bile elsewhere – and all in grown-up, rational language, too! Entirely possible, of course, only if your only major concern is traffic numbers.

    • Karen Whiteley says:

      I meant ‘isn’t traffic numbers’…

    • Jane Da Vall says:

      Karen,

      Yes, absolutely, traffic is what it all about. I think they must like being popular for a change, but as a long term strategy it is terminal for the Guardian. They earned £30-40M in advertising revenue last year. Their operating costs are ten times that amount.

      Traffic does not pay enough, particularly their kind of traffic, which is Mail Online readers, but the angry male readers, not the celeb-obsessed advertising-friendly female readers.

      Also, how do they expect to sustain a majority right wing readership with their editorial policy going forward? As online media supersedes print newspapers, it is inevitable it will be chipped away until they becomes a carbon copy of the Mail. I imagine the immeasurably better commercial operators at the Mail Online will have killed it off long before then.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *