Fewer women in US boardrooms than five years ago
Summary of story from Harvard Business Review, May 3, 2011.
There are fewer women in American boardrooms than five years ago, despite evidence that greater female representation improves corporate performance, according to a new report.
The report, published by the Alliance for Board Diversity, showed that white men held 73 per cent of board seats at Fortune 100 companies in 2010, up from 71 per cent in 2004.
White women made up 15 per cent in 2010 compared to 14 per cent in 2004.
The representation of minorities has also diminished, going from 15 to 13 per cent.
Women account for just 3 per cent of Fortune 500 chief executives and 7.6 per cent of Fortune 500 top earner positions.
While America may be falling behind, the slightly better news is that representation of women in high-paying positions is improving in other countries, with many European governments setting quotas for women on boards of directors.
Norway and Spain have been joined this year by Britain in imposing quotas, while France is set to impose a 20 per cent quota by 2012, which will double by 2016 for the country’s largest 2,500 companies.
The Netherlands and Italy are also looking closely at the issue.
Germany’s chancellor Angela Merkel has called the country’s male-dominated boardrooms a ‘scandal’, and given companies ‘one last chance’ to address the lack of female representation before quotas are brought in by the government.
The European Commission is currently working on plans for a voluntary code urging all public companies to have boards made up of 40 per cent women. Noncompliance will lead to the introduction of mandatory quotas to be introduced within five years.
In not committing to increasing the diversity of their directorial boards, American companies are placing themselves at a disadvantage to their European competitors.
A 2010 McKinsey study found that companies with the greatest number of women on their boards of directors always outperformed those with no female representation, and by a significant margin.
Research in France has also shown that firms with a high representation of women in top management positions fared better in the 2008 financial crisis than their competitors with fewer women.
Speculating on the unique attributes that women bring to the table in a business environment often leads to stereotyping and can be unhelpful.
A better approach is to consider what the absence of women in a boardroom indicates about a company.
A recent Financial Times editorial stressed that an all-male board “now sends negative signals of a conservative mind-set, an inability to look beyond a tried circle of directors and a proneness to damaging group-think.”











