The woman behind the burqa
Heather Kennedy
WVoN co-editor
For French leader Nicolas Sarkozy, story the burqa is “a sign of debasement and subservience”.
Across Europe, the ban of the burqa or niqab, which came into force in France earlier this month, is being pitched as a feminist initiative that will free women from a “male imposed prison”.
And in good faith, many feminists, liberals and Muslims have applauded the ban, arguing that it will remove gender oppression from the French public arena.
Muslim feminist Mona Eltahawy and the campaign group Ni Putes Ni Soumises (Not Whores Not Submissives) are amongst those who believe the ban will sock a punch to sexism.
But this bill has about as much to do with feminism as the Iraq war had to do with weapons of mass destruction.
If the French Government were genuine in their desire to tackle sexism, they would start with equal pay or the number of women in ministerial positions.
In a 2010 report on global gender equality, France had sunk to a dismal 46th behind nations such as Kazakhstan.
This ostensible “feminist” motivation has been cynically rolled out to attract left-wing support and divert attention from the real motivation underlying the bill – a desire to curtail support for the French National Front ahead of 2012 elections.
In a country where mosques are desecrated and Muslims blamed for bitter ethnic and religious clashes, it is a logical development.
Distaste for outward signs of Muslim identity has been growing throughout Northern Europe for years.
In Holland, Koran denouncer Geert Wilder is gaining political popularity. In Belgium, Denmark and Spain, a ban on the veil is already in force.
The veiled woman is an easy target, cast as the bogey-women of failed integration and an exemplar of cultural backwardness.
Quite how the French imagine that they can emancipate a social group by banning the most striking indicator of their identity is a mystery, however.
When Foreign Secretary Jack Straw, using far less rousing language, condemned the burqa in 2006, the result was a spike in attacks against veiled women.
Instead, the ban is a very public rejection of women who adopt the burqa or niqab, a. rejection that will sour public opinion ever further against Muslim women.
And like any slick machine of public policy, the French Government has exonerated themselves in advance for any hostilities that might erupt against women in streets and communities across France.
Sarkozy equates the veil directly with oppression.
The left must avoid the temptation to do the same. I spoke to Angum Ishtiaq, a Muslim woman who runs a training and enterprise project for Asian women in East London.
“Just because you wear the burqa does not mean you cannot be vocal. It does not mean you cannot be educated, opinionated and successful”, she explains.
By equating the veil directly with oppression, she says we impose passivity on the woman beneath.
A recent Guardian (British newspaper) debate entitled ‘Covering the face eliminates the personality behind the veil’ highlights the growing tendency to assume women behind the veil are passive, compliant and silent.
Because of the importance attached to the female face and because of the meaning ascribed to the veil, Northern Europeans view the veiled woman as a mute space.
And taking full advantage of this muteness, we trumpet our condemnations, convinced she is too passive to speak for herself.
So where has the voice of Muslim women been in this debate?
The French inquiry which recommended the ban heard 211 witnesses, only one of whom was a veiled woman. She was seen only after she repeatedly insisted. Maybe European secular society will always equate the veil directly with oppression. But first we must listen.
This argument will be wrongly accused of cultural relativism. Forced marriage is not a symbol of oppression; it is just direct oppression. But the veil is, to western eyes, a symbol of oppression. And the problem with symbols is that they are not fixed.
In Iran and Saudi Arabia, full facial covering for women in public is an obligation. But when a woman in France or Britain adopts the veil, she is stepping out on a limb.
From the outside the veiled woman may look the same from one continent to the next, but whether the veil is adopted as a gendered obligation or as a marginal practice that is at best tolerated and at worst despised, the meaning and motivation is unlikely to be the same.
I don’t doubt for some European Muslims there is a direct link between the veil and power structures that oppress them. But most women in Northern Europe who adopt the burqa are young, educated and the first in their family to do so.
“Intelligent, second and third generation Asians are choosing the burqa as they explore their identity” says Angum.
But why are so many young, educated women born and bred on European soil donning the veil? It’s a question that disturbs us a society. It is far easier to blame the entire phenomenon on a shady horde of bearded “Islamists” than to look to European society for answers.
These young women are choosing the veil not just as Muslims but as British and European citizens. Try as we might, the rise of the veil cannot be attacked as something that exists outside European society.
Younger generations are adopting more visible signs of faith to protect an aspect of their identity they feel is under attack in Europe. Muslim women have also spoken about the veil as a way to escape the obsession with female attractiveness.
If France and the rest of Europe really want to improve life for Muslim women, how about giving their voice a real platform in policy making? In the UK, how about protecting language classes, domestic violence services and other vital life lines for marginalised women?
In the absence of any European policies that genuinely support Muslim women, the real character of this ban shows its sinister face.
















Impressive article!
In my view, alongside the social, political and gender aspects you mention, there is also a definite will from most politicians to foment anti-Muslim sentiments on religious ground.
Chirac was one of the first to bring that will in the open when he said that the ‘Christian’ roots of the European Union had to be included in the European Constitution.
In most countries of Western Europe, there is a growing apartheid against Muslims, which reminds me of how the Jews were treated during the decade before Hitler came to power.
Obliged to respect the separation between Church and State, Sarkozy turned the decree to his advantage by picturing himself as the liberator of Muslim women, enslaved by their condition.
Confronted by a powerful movement – Islam’s renaissance – in a time when their own religious grounds have become for the least uncertain, politicians might have opted for the lesser evil (apartheid), for fear history – the Muslim conquests – might repeat itself.
this is a very difficult issue with no clearcut answers. i am of several warring ‘minds’ on the issue, and since i am not muslim, i don’t believe my opinion is terribly important. i am supportive of freedom of expression (i.e. wearing the veil), and also think the whole idea of covering from head to foot is ridiculous, inconvenient, bulky and kind of silly.
the underlying issues of paternal control and the desire to look virginal and ‘good’ and innocent are rarely addressed. 60 years ago, virtuous ‘good girls’ in the west dressed differently from ‘bad girls’, regardless of the truth of the matter. it might be a similar impulse. not to mention a way to handle ‘bad hair days’.