UK ministers told to apologise for 1970s ‘virginity tests’
Summary from the Guardian April 8, 2011
UK ministers are facing demands for an official apology to at least 80 Asian women who were subjected to invasive “virginity tests” by immigration staff when they tried to come to Britain in the late 1970s.
The demands follow the disclosure of confidential Home Office files that show that intimate examinations – used to “check the marital status” of Indian and Pakistani women coming to Britain to marry – were on a far wider scale than was previously known.
The practice was banned in February 1979 after the Guardian exclusively reported that a 35-year-old Indian woman teacher was examined by a male doctor when she arrived at Heathrow to test whether she was a genuine wife-to-be who had not borne children and was still a virgin.
The Home Office initially denied that any internal examination had taken place. However, the recently released Home Office files report the doctor’s version of the examination.
“Penetration of about half an inch made it apparent that she had an intact hymen and no other internal examination was made …
“The only time she was bare chested was for the X-ray examination… The doctor told the immigration officer verbally that the lady had not had children and she was then given conditional leave to enter for three months as a fiancee.”
The file also reveals that after the incident became public the Home Office offered the woman £500 to ensure she did not sue.
The payment, offered through her solicitors, was to be “in recognition of the distress she had been caused” but she also had to agree “not to initiate any proceedings against the Home Office”.
It was stressed that the payment was not “compensation”, which would have implied that immigration staff had acted improperly.
Australian academics, Marinella Marmo and Evan Smith of Flinders University law school, Adelaide, said the use of gynaecological examinations on migrant women from the Indian subcontinent in the 1970s was one of the gravest abuses of discretionary powers in British immigration history.
“A proper apology that acknowledged ‘virginity testing’ was not an isolated incident was never issued,” they said.
The demand for an apology was backed by the Joint Council for the Welfare of Immigrants (JCWI), which was involved in the original 1979 case.
Hina Majid, the JCWI’s legal policy director, said: “This represents yet another shameful chapter in the ignominious history of British immigration control.
“It is deeply regrettable that no apology has ever been rendered to those women who underwent this degrading and discriminatory practice.
“Whilst this is a practice of the past, it is demonstrative of a wider, and indeed ongoing tendency to sideline women in immigration policy making.”
Majid continued, saying, ” in 2011 we may no longer be virginity testing South Asian brides, the sad reality is that many migrant women continue to be denied equal treatment, and the full enjoyment of their human rights”.











