SlutWalking challenges culture that blames victims
Kate Suttle
Freelance journalist
Although organisers originally expected 30 people, around 2000 participated in Saturday’s SlutWalk in Boston.
As reported in the UK in the Guardian and on WVoN, the SlutWalking movement began in Canada in January, sparked by a Toronto police officer’s advice to a group of university students that ‘women should avoid dressing like sluts in order not to be victimised’.
He then withdrew his remark and apologised, but not before it had provoked an international response seeking to reclaim the term ‘slut’ and to undermine the culture of blaming victims of sexual violence. Marches have been organised across America and the world.
The movement has come under scrutiny in the Guardian by academics Gail Dines and Wendy J Murphy who criticise the organisers’ efforts to ‘re-appropriate’ the word slut.
They argue that it fails to constructively address the real issue – how women can achieve autonomy over their sexuality.
Although their argument has some validity, it does not really acknowledge that SlutWalking is essentially about rape and the right for women not to be sexually violated. This is why, despite its potential flaws, it is an important phenomenon.
According to the European Institute for Gender Equality, sexual violence still carries some of the lowest conviction rates for any crime in the European Union.
As if it needed saying, the SlutWalking movement and the comment that instigated it are further sobering reminders of the mournful inadequacy of society’s response to sexual violence and of the lack of constructive dialogue on the subject.
Amnesty International reports that a woman is raped every six minutes in the US while UK based charity Rape Crisis says that five per cent of women and 0.4 per cent of men experience rape.
The idea that the victims should be blamed for the crime perpetrated on them has to be challenged publicly and loudly.
The very size and fervour of SlutWalking is in itself a sad testament to the lingering persistence of a terrible problem.
Essential efforts to radically improve the way society handles rape will be severely compromised if our society remains silent on the issue.
Like many social movements before it, SlutWalking is not a panacea but it has galvanised thousands more men and women to take action against this most invasive of crimes.
SlutWalking, London, will take place on 11 June.
















I don’t think anyone can contend that every woman has a right not to be sexually violated. With his poorly worded ‘advice’, this copper has at least got people reading about conviction rates for sexual offences. However I don’t find his comments quite as sensational as I feel I ought to. I agree that the blame is 100% at the door of the rapist, but I would also contend that any sensible person should always take precautions to protect themselves from the less perfect aspects of our world. If I knew I had to walk through a dangerous area on my way home, I would be sure not to wear an expensive watch, or chat away on my iphone. If I was mugged, the blame would still be 100% at the door of the muggers. But is a risk I could have minimized.
To reiterate, I’m not trying to say what women should or should not be able to wear. The rape victim takes no blame for the horrible crime that is carried out against them. Risk of rape should not exist, but it does at the moment it does. So please take precautions and protect yourself.
—————
I confess, this was not he most thought out response. But, after the tragedy of those conviction statistics, it was the first thing that popped into my head. I tried t think of a way I could personally relate to the situation (obviously mugging is nothing to rape). Feel free to tear this response apart, always keen to learn.
I understand the above point but like you said you cannot compare being robbed to being raped. The idea of what is too sexy and therefore risky is completely in the eye of the rapist and therefore is nothing like an expensive watch which is universally a sign of wealth. Therefore I don’t understand how a person could avoid rape. I have had 4 close friends of mine raped in their lifetime and 3 of them were date rape and had absolutely nothing to do with the clothes they were wearing. I could be wrong but I believe the percentage for date rape is actually higher than rape by a stranger which would make the argument that it is because of clothing completely null and void. I think it is sad that crimes against woman are still not prosecuted like theft and that we continue to humiliate and put potential blame on the victim of arguably the worst crime one can commit. I don’t have the answers, but I don’t think the solution is to wear turtlenecks sweaters.
Hi dd5447
Thank you for your response. As Julie says it is difficult to compare rape with any other kind of violation because it is such a personal intrusion on a body, whether the person who is raped is female or male. However, I do take your point, as every women does, that in our society we have to take care of ourselves because it just isn’t safe out there for women. As a former peacekeeping guy said it is more dangerous to be a woman than a soldier in modern conflict (http://reliefweb.int/node/300464) – I would argue that women are in a perpetual conflict every day in terms of protecting our bodies from attack. And, we need to name this to shame it – we can’t keep SAYING that we should be able to walk around wearing whatever we want and think that that is going to work…because it doesn’t. That doesn’t mean we shouldn’t keep saying it, but it does mean that we also need to name the threat – which is that women are at risk of rape from male rapists ALL THE TIME and that is how it is. And, until we manage to change this culture (with the help of men who are not rapists and who I like to believe are the majority of men, just like you) then we need to protect ourselves.
The Commander that said “It is now more dangerous to be a woman than to be a soldier in modern conflict” was only referring to women in conflict zones, like Kenya or the Congo – not Britain or any other reasonably peaceful country. So let’s not start assuming we’re in any way at risk of the same sort of vicious assualts that women in those countries face on a daily basis.
Rape is a problem but the discussions about it need to grow up, in my opinion, and I don’t think any amount of “SlutWalks” are going to help. We should be able to question how wise a woman or man’s decisions were before the crime occured and STILL be able to put the full blame at the perpetrators door. For example who can honestly say that the McCann parents were acting responsibily when they left their three young children alone, resulting in the kidnap of Madeleine? They are not to blame for what happened, but had they made wiser choices the risk would have been massively decreased, even removed altogether.
And those that think that mugging is in no way comparable to rape should keep in mind some muggings are incredibly violent and traumatise the survivors for years, if not for the rest of their lives. The trauma it causes phycically and mentally may not be the same as that caused by rape but it is comparable. Take a look at this poor woman and tell me she’s not going to traumatised for the rest of her life http://www.metro.co.uk/news/862888-mugging-victim-his-punch-was-like-being-hit-by-a-car.
I get so tired of debates on rape that descend into one side demanding that women act more responsibly versus the other side complaining of victim blaming. The whole discussion is pointless. Most rape happens in relationships and takes place at home. I don’t know of any evidence that a woman’s dress has any impact at all on her chances of being raped. Clearly, taking care when travelling at night reduces the risk of attack for both men and women, but this is already drummed into girls, in particular, from a young age.
Can we acknowledge that women should and do take care for their safety and that they have a right to be out in public and to the protection of the law, whether or not they act responsibly? Then maybe discussion could turn to how to make that protection mean something in public and in private.
Have to say I’m with Jane on this one. The debate about Slutwalk is in danger of falling into a hole where feminists start talking about this concept of ‘taking responsibility’ for our behaviour to ‘avoid’ being raped.
It’s a false argument, and actually, a really offensive one that says much more about our attitudes towards women and women’s sexuality than it does about rape.
I’ve been really interested in the feedback I’m getting informally – emails, facebook posts, tweets – on the Slutwalk in London. I’m seeing a lot of anger and misunderstanding about the point of the walk and I think the one responsibility we all have in common – myself included, I had the same reaction when I first heard about it – is to find out more before we start to judge the idea.
In this spirit, there’s a really great post over at Hollaback (campaign to end street harassment) that gives the transcript and original film of Jaclyn Friedman’s speech at the Boston Slutwalk.
http://www.ihollaback.org/blog/2011/05/10/sluts-are-loud-were-messy-we-dont-behave/
I think she really captures a lot of common ground for feminists. We’re all trying to achieve the same broad goals, and this aptitude for in-fighting is fundamentally divisive and falls straight into the hands of the forces we’re trying to overcome.
Diversity of opinion is one of the things about the feminist ‘movement’ that makes me most proud. But in discussing our differences, I think we have to be careful not to lose sight of our common ground.
The problem though is that the debate about taking precautions vs blaming the victim is more often than not shot down before it starts, with the stance of “there’s nothing the victim could do to reduce the risk” being the winning argument by default. I’m tired of the notion of no one taking any responsibility for their decisions and choices – whether they be the attacked or the attacker.
I’m afraid I just can’t take the SlutWalk seriously. It brings to mind the moment in Clerks 2 in the burger store, when one character uses the term “Porch Monkey”, offending two African American customers, with him claiming that it’s not a racial slur – even though it is – and that he’s going to “take it back”. Slut is an insult and it will always be an insult. The very fact SlutWalk’s been so misunderstood by so many is an indication of how naive and short sighted it is, IMO.
The fact is only by educating men, women and particularly children about rape (and who is actually doing it) do we have any hope of improving the situation so it a. doesn’t happen as much, and b. results in a conviction when it does. As a teenager I was terrified of rape – but only stranger rape. That was what I read in the papers, what was reported on the news, what crime shows focused on and what everyone talked about. But because of fear I read about rape, and I learned the realities. Education and getting the right information out there is key, and the media’s role is an important and powerful one. Sadly the view seems to be that storylines around a woman being forced to have sex with her husband doesn’t make as compelling (or comfortable) viewing as seeing a woman being grabbed by a masked stranger in a park.
A lot more needs to be done to know what’s really going on with rape and to understand, or at least identify, the men that are doing it. There is a brilliant piece about this on http://yesmeansyesblog.wordpress.com/2009/11/12/meet-the-predators/ and should be mandatory reading. What’s best about it is it doesn’t suggest all men as potential attackers nor does it suggest women as asking for it. The rapists questioned reveal much about how many attacks they’ve committed, and in what context. And almost all say they will target someone they know. The men that rape can teach us much – if we’re willing to listen.