Issues of ethics and logic facing Republican presidential candidates
Summary of story from AmericaMagazine, May 9, 2011
Would you support water-boarding terror suspects under certain circumstances? Fox News’ Chris Wallace asked those gathered on a stage in South Carolina last week at an event billed as the first Republican presidential primary.
Raising their hands to signify that they would support water-boarding were Herman Cain, the former CEO of Godfather’s Pizza; Tim Pawlentey, former governor of Minnesota; and Rick Santorum, former senator from Pennsylvania.
Over at The Dish journalist Andrew Sullivan wonders if Catholic Church leaders, specifically bishops, will offer warnings to Catholic politicians who support torture like those they give to people who support liberal abortion laws.
Rick Santorum, for example, often identifies himself as a deeply devout Catholic, and he is a loud voice in opposition to abortion and gay marriage.
On these issues, Santorum certainly echoes the views of Catholic bishops (if not the Catholic laity).
But on the issue of torture, Ricky Santorum clearly deviates from church teaching.
Sullivan asks: What are the odds that they will consider denying him communion for backing the torture of terror suspects?
If both abortion and torture are considered to be affronts to the dignity of the human person, the church should speak up boldly and clearly.











