subscribe: Posts | Comments

Buying sex, not T-shirts, is ‘a better way to help Cambodian women’

0 comments

Summary of story from Slate, May 19, 2011

Ken Silverstein, a journalist for Slate, argues that buying sex might be a better way to help Cambodian women than buying a T-shirt.

He asserts that for young women, work in the sex industry – which includes hostess bars, karaoke bars, massage parlors, and freelance prostitution – is one of the few alternatives to work in the apparel industry, which produces 90 percent of the country’s export earnings.

The sex and apparel sectors draw from the same labor pool: young, poorly educated women from the impoverished countryside who send part of their earnings home to support their families. Almost all of the country’s 350,000 apparel workers are women.

Estimates of sex-industry workers, he says, range from about 20,000 to 100,000; the lower number is probably far closer to the truth as the latter comes from the hyperbolic, fundraising-driven claims of anti-trafficking organizations, which seem to assume that almost every sex worker is a “slave.”

A more likely estimate of the percentage of trafficked prostitutes is 10 percent.

Comparing the pros and cons of factory work compared to sex work, he concludes that: “Sex work is just as much of a dead-end job as apparel work; when women get older, they either find something else to do or move from clubs and bars to the street.”

Are sex workers exploited, he asks? Yes, but then so are textile workers.

“A lot of women no longer want apparel jobs,” Tola Moeun, a labor-rights activist with a group called the Community Legal Education Center, said.

“When prostitution offers a better life, our factory owners need to think about more than their profit margins.”

WVoN co-editor comment: I very rarely find myself speechless, but I had one of those moments as I was reading this article.

For Cambodian women ‘slavery’, either as a prostitute or as a sweatshop worker, is the only alternative. And according to Mr Silverstein, that is not bad, not bad at all.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *