subscribe: Posts | Comments

Human trafficking “not a priority” for the Met

1 comment

Summary of stories from The Guardian and BBC News, May 20, 2011.

WVoN reported yesterday that four women who claimed they were forced into slavery in London had won a payout from the Metropolitan police.

More details have now emerged from the ruling handed down on Friday, in which Mr Justice Wyn Williams said the Met had breached the victims’ rights under articles 3 and 4 of the European convention on human rights, adding that the police “did nothing to commence an effective investigation”.

“Their names were known to the police, they wanted their complaints to be investigated.

“They were directly affected by the failure to carry out an effective investigation.”

One of the alleged victims had approached police seeking help in 2004 while she was still being held by the family. On Friday she said: “It took all the courage I had to walk into Southgate police station and Enfield social services to ask for help in 2004 but they sent me back to my abusers and then blamed me.”

The other three women sought help once they had escaped their abusers in 2007 with the help of organisations including Hackney Community Law Centre (HCLC) and the campaign group Africans Unite Against Child Abuse (AFRUCA).

The Met agreed to undertake an investigation into the claimants’ allegations of abuse in 2009 after being threatened with judicial review.

The subsequent inquiry led to the conviction of a church pastor who was found guilty of trafficking children into the UK for use as domestic “slaves”.

According to Bhatt Murphy, the women’s solicitors, the ruling will mean police forces across England and Wales owe a duty of care under the Human Rights Act to investigate credible allegations of “ongoing or past servitude”.

Following the ruling, a Met spokesman said: “It is of course a matter of deep regret that the claimants did not receive the levels of service which they expected. We will now carefully consider the judgment.”

Tony Murphy, of Bhatt Murphy, criticised the police for fighting the case. He said: “[The] decision to fight this case sends a dangerous message to officers that combating human trafficking is not a priority for the Met.”

Nathaniel Matthews, of HCLC, said: “It is a depressingly familiar pattern to see victims of crime blamed for the failings of the criminal justice system. We have seen this happen with rape victims, the mentally ill and now with trafficking victims.”

  1. vicki wharton says:

    I think the fact the police chose to fight this case doesn’t send a message – it illustrates by their actions that certain classes of people – slaves, rape victims, gender violence victims and the disabled – live outside the law, with no real protection from the police, who have more empathy with the persecutors …

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *