subscribe: Posts | Comments

‘Plainly vulnerable girl’ gets suspended sentence after false rape claim

1 comment

Summary of story from the BBC, May 25, 2011

A girl who had sex with three men and then claimed she had been raped has been given a suspended sentence.

Five men, aged 18 to 21, were later arrested after Hannah Patenall, then 17, accused them of raping her in Bedford town centre.

When interviewed, the men told detectives that Patenall had approached them in the street and offered them sex.

The court heard police later examined CCTV footage and saw the girl walking with the men and with her arm around one and kissing one.

One of the men later found a recording on his phone of his sexual encounter with Ms Patenall which showed she had consented, Luton Crown Court heard.

Two of the men spent 24 hours in police custody, three spent 13 hours and all were asked to provide body fluid samples. They were also on police bail for five weeks.

Judge Michael Kay said that although the five men had not deserved what happened following their encounter with the girl, they were not “basking in glory” because of their behaviour.

He said Ms Patenall was “plainly vulnerable, 17 at the time and these young men were quite prepared to take advantage of the unfortunate situation.”

As well as a 12-month sentence in a young offenders’ institution suspended for two years, Patenall was made the subject of a mental health treatment requirement for the next 18 months.

WVoN comment: This is clearly a very sad case of a young woman who, for whatever reason, approached three complete strangers in the street and asked them for sex. My question is this – did it not occur to any of the men that it was pretty strange behaviour? Or did it just not matter to them?

  1. Jackie says:

    I agree with the judge and with the WVON comment. This young woman appears to be very vulnerable and the males concerned exploited that. I think its appalling that these men could have sex without thought or question, one after the other, with a young woman who had approached them in the street. It raises all sorts of questions about the impersonal and exploitative nature of much male sexuality.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *