New York rape case ‘He said/ she said’ says juror
Summary of story from Mail Online, May 27, 2011
“It came down to he said/she said,” these are the words used by juror Eric Casiano to describe the seven week trial that ended in New York yesterday.
The trial, in which police officers Ken Moreno and Frank Mata stood accused of raping a drunk woman, ended in their acquittal (see WvoN story).
Speaking to the New York Post, fellow juror Richard Schimenti said: “No one is ever going to know what happened in that apartment because [the victim] was blacked out.”
He went on to say: “The prosecution really failed to prove their case. There was no evidence of a rape – except that she said it.”
However, in a secretly taped conversation, officer Moreno had admitted to using a condom. The defence later dismissed this alleged confession as a lie on Moreno’s part to stop the woman from making a scene.
Juror Eric Casiano went on to say: “There were holes in his and her stories.”
“The law says if you’re not sure, if there is reasonable doubt, you have to say not guilty,” he added.
“She was drunk and the two cops were there. I couldn’t tell you what happened in that room.”
WVoN comment: Had this trial taken place in Scotland I suspect the verdict would have been “not proven” as opposed to “acquitted”.
These comments from the jury reinforce my suspicion that although the process of justice may have been concluded, justice may not have been served.
















Not proven and not guilty mean the same thing in Scotland, not guilty. There is a social stigma associated with not proven since it is seen as a lesser acquittal however it is legally the same verdict. The three verdict system comes from 1728 when a jury (which had to decide if the charges were proven or not proven) decided to judge the law itself (as jurors are allowed to) and voted not guilty, as in proven but we won’t allow a sentence passed.
So ‘not guilty’ actually meant quite the opposite in Scotland originally, but the jury objected to the law itself.
It must often be the case that justice is not served where the evidence consists only of the conflicting testimonies of victim and defendant and the burden of proof favours the defendant.
However, in this case, that was not the only evidence. The defendants actions and statements on and after the night in question were also heard in evidence, including one as good as admitting his guilt on tape.
The jurors seem to be saying that because they could not be certain what had happened, because the woman was incapacitated, they could not convict. If so that is a jury that has misunderstood the burden of proof, it is not certainty. They must look at the entirety of the evidence and have the option of concluding that, while it is not impossible to doubt guilt, it is not a reasonable conclusion to draw, and the defendant is, therefore, found guilty.
I hadn’t realised that that was the origin of Scotland’s third verdict.
However as Jane has pointed out, had this jury been given the option not to assign guilt, they may not have done so. Unfortunately, in being forced to acquit the accused due to an inability to comprehend the events of the night in question, there is an implication of guilt that has been applied to the woman.
Now, rape trials where the victim was drunk are notorious for their lack of clear-cut evidence. This trial was no exception and neither was the behaviour of the defence which saw one of Moreno’s lawyers compare vaginas to Venus fly traps.
The last thing I want is for rape conviction rates to drop and for women to feel even less confident in reporting the crime than they are now. If Juries were given the option to use a “not proven” verdict, one which meant that neither guilt nor innocence could clearly be established, there is a worry that it might be overused.
However, in this case the wealth of contradictory evidence, the vehemence involved in the defence, and the wariness of the jury to convict, does seem to suggest that there are still serious improvements to be made in how rape trials are conducted.
Regardless of the verdict, the outcry against this trial seems to be a clear indicator that public faith in it has not been restored.
As I said in my previous post, the police officer admitted he had sex but then said he was lying, he lied to his work about his whereabouts on the night, making up 911 calls to give him an opportunity to return to the woman’s flat 3 times which is recorded on video. At what point does the jury say to itself this man has proved beyond all reasonable doubt that he lies to get what he wants whenever he wants. He confessed on tape, he was caught on camera, the witness recalled him raping her whilst she was incapicitated and not even in a state to give consent since she was under the influence of a drug which is why the officers were taking her home … what more evidence needs to be given? Everything he has said he has changed and reverted depending on who he is speaking to … and why believe the word of a proven liar?
Yes, I think it is possible that would happen if ‘not proven’ was an option. In fact juries do convict in more than half of rape cases. Unfortunately, the CPS will not put a case to them which doesnt stagger under the weight of its evidence and, usually, victims. At first conviction, the average rapist has seven victims. That is seven victims that actually reported the crime.
I should say, at their first conviction, rapists have on average seven victims. I don’t know what an average rapist is.
uh….The thing is, to a normal person, it was proven beyond a reasonable doubt:
1- Cops do NOT take her to her front door and instruct her to be careful, and then say “good night”, instead they enter her apartment. Some guys wait in the living room, while another cop takes her into the bedroom, removes her clothes and gets into bed with her.
2- Victim remembers the cop rolling down her tights
3-The cops call in fake 911 calls all night and keep returning to her apartment and entering.
4- Rapist admits on the phone that he used a condom
5- They were also found guilty of theft, which proves they are dishonest
(To any one with even 1/10th of a brain, there is proof. The jury was clearly brain-dead.)