Equality has cost women in the UK their state pension
Laith Khalaf
Pensions analyst, Hargeaves Lansdown
A clash over the state pension age will take place next Monday in the House of Commons, and probably outside it too.
The main source of conflict will be the UK government’s plans to bring forward increases to the state pension age for women.
Many see this policy as discriminatory, but strangely it is European equality legislation which has necessitated such a rapid increase.
The state pension age for women was in fact already on its way up before the coalition government got involved.
The original trajectory was set out in 1995, with the age at which women could draw their state pensions rising from 60 to 65 between 2010 and 2020. However the current government wants to move the goalposts on a bit and increase the state pension age to 66 for all.
This policy received its first public outing in October 2009 in George Osborne’s speech to the Conservative Party Conference. At that time the plan was notably different however.
The then Shadow Chancellor put it succinctly enough: ‘Our aim will be to bring forward the date when the pension age rises…
‘For men this means the pension age will not start to rise to 66 until at least 2016. For women this means the pension age will not start to rise from 65 to 66 until at least 2020.’
Fast forward one year to October 2010: Mr Osborne is now Chancellor. He announces the increase in state pension age as a government policy, however it has shifted subtly, but significantly.
The policy (as it stands now) increases women’s state pension age faster, to 65 by 2018. Both men and women’s state pension age then rises to 66 in tandem, by 2020.
In the interim some well-informed civil servant had no doubt referred Mr Osborne to European Union Directive 79/7. This requires EU member states to implement equal treatment between men and women in social security matters.
Any change to the state pension which either increased the existing gap between men and women or delayed the point at which the pension ages became equal would probably breach the terms of the Directive.
The government could not therefore increase the state pension age for men until women were brought level with them.
Hence the government now find themselves under attack for discriminating against women as a result of bowing to equality legislation. The opposition has been vocal and some of its arguments do have merit.
Women born between 6 April 1953 and 5 April 1960 will be affected by the proposed changes to some extent. These women have relatively little time to make alternative retirement savings of their own.
Indeed they have already had to adapt their expectations as a result of the 1995 legislation which increased their state pension age from 60 to 65.
However in that instance they were given ample notice of that change, which did not start until 2010 – 85% of the women affected will see their pension age increase by less than a year.
However a significant minority, estimated at around 300,000, will see their state pension age increase by 18 months to two years.
It is women born between 6 December 1953 and 5 October 1954 who will suffer this breath-taking hike in pension age, and it is perhaps the disproportionate impact on these women which gives opponents of the policy their most effective weapon.
Irrespective of the outcome of this particular battle, the war is only heading in one direction, and that is a higher state pension age for both men and women – 66 is just the start, and a pension age of 70 in the not too distant future is not unthinkable.
Private savings are therefore a must for those who don’t want their retirement to be left entirely at the mercy of the state.











