subscribe: Posts | Comments

Womaneconomics? More like a wolf in sheep’s clothing

0 comments

Summary of story from the Observer, June 19, 2011

There is no shortage of material on the 2008 financial crisis, the reverberations of which we will no doubt be feeling for the next decade, and it is unsurprising that the vast majority of this is male dominated.

The final report of the Financial Crisis Inquiry Commission of the US Treasury does not include the words “she”, “woman” or “her” on any of its 662 pages. It is a book, like most historical tragedies, written about the follies and hubris of men.

The Big Short, Michael Lewis’ bestseller lets you into the bedrooms and boardrooms of the individual corporate men who catastrophically lost billions of dollars. It gives the crash a human face, and once again that face is universally male.

Lewis, a one-time bond trader gave evidence to the Crisis Inquiry Commission over the course of its 18-month sitting. In the end, however, he refused to sign off the report. He was not a fan.

What the committee failed to do, in Lewis’ eyes, was to look for aspects or circumstances that might have changed in Wall Street or the City, the things that might have made individuals on the trading floors act in ways that were seen to be entirely, unprecedentedly, reckless.

When he came to consider these things himself, Lewis felt that perhaps chief among the unprecedented novelties was women.

“Of course,” he observed, with tongue firmly in cheek, “the women who flooded into Wall Street firms before the crisis weren’t typically permitted to take big financial risks.

“As a rule they remained in the background, as ‘helpmates’. But their presence clearly distorted the judgment of male bond traders – though the mechanics of their influence remains unexplored by the commission.

“They may have compelled the male risk-takers to ‘show off for the ladies’, for instance, or perhaps they merely asked annoying questions and undermined the risk-takers’ confidence.

“At any rate, one sure sign of the importance of women in the crisis is the market’s subsequent response: to purge women from senior Wall Street roles…”

How earnest this is, I don’t know, but speaking at the London School of Economics some time later, Lewis was asked what single thing he would do to reform the markets and prevent such a catastrophe happening again.

He said: “I would take steps to have 50% of women in risk positions in banks.”

Pressed on this, he went on to suggest how science reveals that women in general make smarter decisions regarding investment than men, that when it comes to money, women in couples are demonstrably better at evaluating risk than their partners, and single women much better still.

A recent study of 2.7 million personal investors found that during the financial crisis of 2008 and 2009, men were much more likely than women to sell any shares they owned at stock market lows. The author suggested that male investors, as a group, appeared to be overconfident.

However, in order for these results to be applicable, researchers are looking to science, in particular “neuroeconomics”, to add weight to these behavioural observations.

Neuroeconomics proposes the idea that you will create a better understanding of how people make economic choices if you bring to bear advances in neurobiology and brain chemistry and behavioural psychology alongside traditional economic maths models.

Not surprisingly, neuroeconomics has plenty to say about the question of whether there is any gender difference regarding decision-making in high-pressure situations.

There has been a lot of interest in the role of hormones in risk-taking behaviour, with John Coates leading research in the area. Coates, and his research associate Joe Herbert, are especially interested in testosterone and cortisol (see WVoN story).

They not only discovered that a trader’s morning testosterone level could be used to predict his day’s profitability.

They also found that a trader’s cortisol rose with both the variance of his trading results and the volatility of the market. The results pointed to a further possibility: as volatility increased, the hormones seemed to shift risk preferences and even affect a trader’s ability to engage in rational choice.

Joe Herbert said: “What is clear is that there are neurological differences between the sexes. Women, in very general terms, are less competitive, and less concerned with the status of being successful.

“If you want to make women more present, you have to remember two things: the world they are coming into is a man-made world. The financial world. So, either they become surrogate men… or you change the world.”

In Britain only 5.5% of executive directors in FTSE 100 companies are women. On city trading floors, the percentage remains, for some of the reasons outlined above, at around 3% or 4%. Testosterone rules.

The country that has attempted most radically to change this balance is Norway, where a Conservative minister imposed a quota of 40% female directors in every boardroom.

Most of the data suggests the initiative has been a great success, both culturally and commercially (though some, male, commentators argue that the turnaround is better explained by the spike in oil prices).

It would be hard to find many people in the city, even among women, who would favour quotas, though that argument can be made.

John Coates suggests a practical solution. “The question is not whether men are risk takers and women are risk-averse. It is more what kind of risk do they want to take? My hunch is that women don’t like high-frequency trading, so what you have to do is change the accounting period over which they are judged.”

WVoN comment: I find so much of this speculation and research hard to swallow. It’s thoroughly frustrating for me to see the financial sector reduced to a battle of the sexes, in the most base and boring way. I can’t help but compare it in my mind to the parliamentary buck always being thrust at the “other” political party.

I think Michael Lewis’ two, apparently contradictory, statements contain within them an element of truth. The idea that women shouldn’t be allowed to participate in the sector, cohabits with the thought that more women would bring a balance.

It’s an example of the financial sector’s ability to vigorously nod its head as it’s bellowing the word ‘no!’ .

I have so many thoughts on this, but I will keep it brief. Women running banks, stock markets, becoming bond traders and being more than an eye through the keyhole in boardrooms doesn’t matter much, it’s still capitalism.

I’m with Herbert. We need to change to world.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *