subscribe: Posts | Comments

Women in boardrooms should be “conscious of their language”

2 comments

Summary of story from the Observer, June 19, 2011

Linguistics expert Dr Judith Baxter has claimed that tone of language is holding women back from reaching the top tiers of corporations.

Her claim is supported by an 18-month study into the speaking patterns of men and women at meetings in seven major well-known companies, including two in the FTSE-100.

The research found that women were four times more likely than men to be self-deprecating, use humour and speak indirectly or apologetically when broaching difficult subjects with board members in order to avoid conflict.

When employed effectively, this kind of language could be a useful tool to manipulate those around them, she claimed, but self-deprecation and an apologetic style were risky because striking a wrong note could lead to appearing defensive and weak.

Baxter, a lecturer in applied linguistics at Aston University, said women were left open to accusations that they were not fully in control of their arguments, which could lead to a complete loss of authority during meetings.

“They have to work really hard to hit the right note with their colleagues,” she said. “I have seen a woman use all the wrong linguistic strategies, and she lost the room.”

Baxter said she had heard one woman director, who had spoken just twice in a meeting, say: “Sorry, sorry, I’m talking too much, I’m talking too much.”

According to the annual Female FTSE Board report from Cranfield University School of Management, the proportion of women on the boards of FTSE-100 companies is only 12.5%, a marginal rise on the previous year.

Helena Morrissey, 44, the chief executive of money management firm Newton, said she did not want women to start acting like men, but they should be conscious of their language.

“It may be seen as a bit of weakness on the part of women, because you are not playing the game in the same way. Maybe subconsciously there is a feeling that this person isn’t as decisive, can’t hold her own, is unsure of her arguments,” she said.

“Don’t say ‘you aren’t going to like this’; just say it and know that is not making yourself be like the man,” Morrissey continued.

“You will get your point across and no one is going to think badly [of you]. Well they might, but that is all part of the discussion and the hammer and tongues.”

  1. “Hammer and tongues”? Nice turn of phrase. 🙂

    I’ve found this to be true even in something like online discussion – men will say their piece then insist that it is correct until such time as someone comes up with facts and figures to disprove it, women are more likely to hedge with phrases like ‘I read’ or ‘I was told’. Useful tactics but I can see how it seems less assertive or assured in some cases.

    Also – obviously those are generalisations, not everyone who identifies as a man is so definite in his position, not everyone who identifies as a woman adds provisos to their arguments.

    • Jane Da Vall says:

      One can usually tell apart the writing and speech styles of men and women. I expect the distinction is a learned one, but I don’t know. I do know that attempting to compete with men by mimicking them, whether it be the way men speak, think or act is not a game women can win. Nor is it any way to acquire the self respect and confidence that leads to success.

      In public life today, the way men do things is the ‘right’ way. The City has ably demonstrated that very often it isn’t the best way, but this knowledge has changed nothing. Results are irrelevant. Men set the rules of engagement to suit themselves. If women are to accede to positions of power in more than the token numbers we see today, we have to change this. We have to overturn the rule that makes us wrong by definition.

      To do this we have to start using our political majority. Caitlin Moran asks in her new book why women have not come along better since they got the vote. Women are still powerless to secure their physical safety let alone leadership of the boardroom or government and it is because we have never used the votes we have. It is time we did because it is patently clear that no quarter is being given to women in public life. We have to take our rights or they are not rights at all, and we can start by scorning this helpful condemnation of the way we speak.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *