subscribe: Posts | Comments

The Tolkien gender balance

4 comments

Simon King
WVoN Co-Editor

I find it strange that while Tolkien can be attacked for not featuring enough strong women in his works, any discussion of strong heroines inevitably features one of his most famous characters, Eowyn.

I suppose it’s the price that you pay for producing such wide-reaching works of fiction. There will always be people who want something changed.

That’s one of the great things about film adaptations. Casino Royale intensified the suspense and danger that Fleming, at the start of his career, wasn’t in control of.

Blade Runner moved away from the existentialism of Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep and intensified the Noir aspects of the work.

Peter Jackson’s Lord of the Rings films, constrained by time, were able to cut out cumbersome sections such as Concerning Hobbits, Tom Bombadil and the Scouring of the Shire.

But on Sunday Jackson announced that Evangeline Lilly would be playing a “new character” in the Hobbit, the woodland elf “Tauriel”.

I’ll be honest, I wasn’t happy that Arwen, instead of Glorfindel, comes across Aragorn in the Fellowship. I’m still not happy about it, but at least I can understand it as being a way of adding some depth to her character.

I’m having trouble exercising that level of understanding here, mainly because Jackson hasn’t explained why he’s taken this liberty with the text.

Is this an effort to place more strong women within Tolkien’s works?

Is it an attempt to pad out two films that, to be frank, there just isn’t enough source material for?

Or is this some patronising attempt to pander to a female demographic that he thinks might not go and see a film about 15 guys and a dragon?

The fact that Jackson felt it necessary to tell readers “No, there is no romantic connection to Legolas”, suggests the latter. Especially when it leaves the possibility of a romance with other characters hanging.

If he was announcing a new male character, would he have said that? Probably not. Men tend not to need a romantic sub plot to achieve depth of character in films.

If this is Jackson’s attempt to address the lack of strong women within the Hobbit then that sentence undermines it for me.

I wouldn’t have been happy with the announcement of a new character under any circumstances, but something like this that seems so clearly engineered to “make the film suitable for girls”…

Aw heck, it’s insulting.

I love Tolkien, I’ve got a lot of friends that love Tolkien, more of my female friends like Tolkien than my male friends, who tend to prefer Robert Jordan and Stephen Erickson.

No there aren’t a lot of strong women in the Hobbit. Is that a problem? I don’t think so.

Sticking an elf woman in there just so she can fall in love isn’t going to redress the gender balance. That’s what telling new stories is for.

  1. Lesley says:

    Err – how is this women’s views on news exactly? This is a man’s view of a man’s film. Can someone explain how this fits the site?

    • Yes, Lesley, this is Women’s Views on News, a site carrying daily news stories about women. Unlike the mainstream press, we actually think that a male perspective is useful from time to time. This story in particular was interesting precisely because it was written by a man, making some very interesting and perceptive points. Anyone else got a view on this?

  2. Trying to fix something that isn’t broken? I agree with the writer.
    What we need are new stories written with strong female characters. Adding one to an existing story (and one who will probably be the token love interest) is insulting to Tolkien fans.
    In my blog post “Vacancy: heroine to inspire little girls” I wrote: It is through fictional characters that we learn to save the day, become successful, to reach for our dreams. So give us more heroines please.
    I was not referring to learning how to swoon and fall in love!

  3. Nicolette, thank you for your comment, I also agree with the writer completely. He’s taken issue with the malesteam way of dealing with gender ratios in film, plonking women in with a shrug of the shoulders as opposed to developing the character from her spine outwards.

    I really enjoy George RR Martin’s A Song of Ice and Fire, his woman characters have the most phenomenal power and his male characters have vulnerabilities, they are well rounded people with passions and foibles. They make mistakes and they stand up for themselves & others.

    One of the most inspiring things I’ve ever read was on a crimethInc poster under a fantastic representation of an enraged Medusa. It said, “Beauty must be defined as what we are, or else the concept itself is our enemy”. I think that’s a principle that can easily and essentially be imprinted onto our desire for real heroines.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *