Walmart wins, women lose
Summary of story from the Montreal Gazette, here June 24, 2011
Following the news earlier this week that women employees at Walmart could not pursue their class action against the company (see WVoN coverage), journalist Janet Bagnall is in despair.
There are moments, she says, when it feels like the battle for equality for women will never, ever be won.
And she felt it particularly this week with the decision by the US Supreme Court to strike down a class-action claim of sex discrimination by 1.5 million women who either had worked or were still working for Walmart.
While the court acknowledged that “an overall sex-based disparity” exists, Justice Antonin Scalia was unmoved by it.
Writing on behalf of five male judges, he said: “Merely showing that Walmart’s policy of discretion has produced an overall sex-based disparity does not suffice.” (The three women on the Supreme Court, plus one man, disagreed.)
Scalia rejected as “anecdotal” the testimony women put forward in evidence. He found that there was no “specific employment practice” that showed that Walmart purposefully set out to discriminate against women.
What this appears to mean is that if a company does not state in its operating manuals that women are to be underpaid compared to men and promoted less frequently than men, if at all, then women as a class have no chance of winning redress through the courts.
However by the standards of ordinary, everyday discrimination, Walmart’s was fairly systematic, as Liza Featherstone, author of Selling Women Short: The Landmark Battle for Workers’ Rights at WalMart, has shown.
She was interviewed this week by a broadcast program, Democracy Now.
Women were paid less in virtually every single position at Walmart,” she said. “No position was too minor to be exempt from sex discrimination.
There were very few male cashiers, for instance. Those few were paid better than the female cashiers. It didn’t depend where – what region they were in.
This was true all over the country, that women were promoted less easily, less often, despite the fact that the women overall had higher performance evaluations and stayed with the company longer, which, you know, certainly, on both counts, should have been in their favour.
Most of the court’s ruling concerned procedure: because the women did not suffer the “same injury,” they therefore did not constitute a “class,” and so could not seek redress through a class-action suit.
Critics of the ruling found this an outrageous argument. “Courts exist to redress violations of the law, regardless of whether those violations cause their victims to suffer in the same or different ways,” wrote New York lawyer Piper Hoffman at Salon.
The women involved in the case are determined to keep going, saying they will now file smaller suits, as well as claims of workplace discrimination with the US Equal Employment Opportunity Commission.
In other words, back to square one. Start all over again.
Find law firms willing to put up millions of dollars to tackle that old boys’ bastion, the Bush Supreme Court. Waste your life fighting battles that should have been won years ago.
Try tackling, on your own, one of the world’s biggest companies. Good luck.
The ruling is a deeply discouraging message for women, and not only in the United States. Court decisions like this set a standard of obstructionism that too many companies and organizations can be tempted to live down to. You can wish they’ll resist the temptation, but in the absence of court protections, that’s all it amounts to – a wish.
WVoN comment: It is deeply worrying that discrimination can be so blatant and a court of law will still uphold it. We can only encourage the women involved to carry on, but I find it exhausting just to watch, let alone be involved in the fight. However what choice is there?











