subscribe: Posts | Comments

Study finds that men don’t recognise ‘benevolent sexism’

13 comments

Summary of a story from The Huffington Post, June 27,2011

A study in Europe and the USA has found that men continue to endorse sexist behavior even when their attention  is drawn to it, whilst women are more likely to deem the behaviour less acceptable – once they become conscious  of it.

The researchers asked participants to record in a journal sexist comments they encountered on a daily basis. During the trials, subjects were instructed to note instances of sexist behavior toward women, ranging from unwanted sexual attention to blatantly sexist jokes and derogatory comments.

They were also asked to record subtler actions that many would consider harmless: men calling women “girls, ” complimenting them on stereotypically feminine behavior and sheltering them from more “masculine” tasks.

The report cites one incident of this ‘benevolent sexism’ in which a female participant was approached by a complete stranger in a laundromat and asked if she would fold his laundry because she’d be better at it.

Janet Swim of Pennsylvania State University, one of the authors of the study, argues that this kind of sexism is ambiguous, and “people don’t know if they’re kidding, so we discount [such events] one after another.”

The study found that, whilst men were less likely to sanction blatant sexism, ‘benevolent sexism’ was accepted. For example, men did not consider statements such as ‘a good woman should be put on a pedestal’ or ‘in a disaster, women should be saved before men’ to be sexist.

There has been an angry reaction to the study from conservative women (see WVoN story).

Anna Rittger, a blogger for the conservative Independent Women’s Forum, wrote that she first thought the study was a hoax and that she was “beginning to suspect that the modern feminist movement is actually comprised of a bunch of honest-to-goodness misogynists whose goal is to make women look ridiculous.”

But Swim counters that ignoring sexism has consequences and that often the acceptance of subtler forms of sexism can lead to the acceptance of broader forms of gender discrimination.

  1. vicki wharton says:

    I think if we refered to domestic violence as sexist violence, male on female murder as sexist murders and sexual harrassment as sexist harrassment then people might begin to understand women’s sensitivity over sexist behaviour, however well meaning it might be. Superior attitudes based on gender are as dangerous as superior attitudes based on race or religion, but in an effort to keep friends with males around them or to avoid the relentless abuse equal rights campaigners are subjected to, too many women side against their own to keep safe in the same way that some Jewish people worked in the concentration camps or the phenomenon of the black skinheads I remember from the 70s. I think they’re called scabs in unions …?

    • BarryMayor says:

      I’m curious. Would female on male murder be referred to as sexist murder? Would female on male domestic violence (which half of DV incidents are) be referred to as sexist violence?

      • vicki wharton says:

        The figures for DV in the UK are not 50/50, more around 80/20% male on female but I think that any violence that is to make a partner conform to a particular role based on gender should be called sexist violence. Having been subject to sexist abuse and then violence by both my father and two partners, I can testify that certainly a good deal of violence encountered by men in the home can often be as a result of their verbal abuse, emotional blackmail using the upkeep of children as a weapon and plain old self defence by women being pushed, shoved or otherwise assaulted. Not all women are saints – but I think that most men seem to be in a state of denial as to how manipulative and controlling they are in relationships where they want to maintain outdated and unequal power roles in their private homes.

        • BarryMayor says:

          The reports may be 80/20 because of the sexism built into the system. It is virtually impossible to get a report of female on male DV taken seriously, let alone acted on by the police.

          This ABC News hidden video shows that it is virtually impossible for female on male DV to be taken seriously including by the police

          http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iqE0EK93nqw

          So, men seldom report and if they do, THEY are more likely to be arrested than the actual perpetrator. So, they continue to not report for fear of being locked up themselves.

          http://www.csulb.edu/~mfiebert/assault.htm

          So, if a woman slaps a man because she feels he insulted her in some way, is that sexist violence? If a wife pushes a husband away because she doesn’t want him close to her at that time, is that sexist violence?

          “I think that most men seem to be in a state of denial as to how manipulative and controlling they are in relationships where they want to maintain outdated and unequal power roles in their private homes.”

          That statement is where feminists differ from regular women. Feminists see “most men” as “manipulative” and “controlling” whereas most ladies (non-feminists) see men as no more “controlling” or “manipulative” than women.

          This anti-male view of the world (that you well exemplified in your statement above) colors and clouds how feminists see and perceive most human interaction. It is that view of males that continues to reinforce feminism’s long held reputation as proverbial “man-haters.”

  2. BarryMayor says:

    “The report cites one incident of this ‘benevolent sexism’ in which a female participant was approached by a complete stranger in a laundromat and asked if she would fold his laundry because she’d be better at it.”

    I have another one just like that. A woman with a flat tire flagged down a man she’d never seen and asked if he could change the tire for since he was probably better at it. Now that’s blatant sexism.

    • You’re seriously comparing “folding laundry” to “changing a tyre”? You think those two things are as difficult as each other? Get real.

      Folding laundry is easy, anyone can do it. No one, male or female has any excuse in trying to fob it off on someone else. Changing a tyre is manually difficult, and can be struggle for one person to do alone, regardless of their gender. It requires physical strength, which generally speaking men have more of then women. So unsurprisingly some women will ask a man, as they will assume he’s strong enough to help her.

      I will only agree that a woman flagging a man down to ask him to change her tyre is sexist if she ignored a number of women who she could have asked to help her instead. Likewise the laundry example is only sexist if the man in question didn’t ask men to help but specifically targeted the woman.

      (p.s. and one example of sexism does not negate the other – the way you say “Now that’s blatant sexism” suggests that the other example isn’t. BOTH are equally sexist, depending on context.)

      • Alexa, I don’t believe BarryMayor is here to have a rational debate. It is nice to know someone else is reading the comments he’s leaving though. 🙂

      • vicki wharton says:

        I think that both are sexist – and maintained by men and women that don’t want the challenge of trying out new skills. Some women shy away from learning how to change a tyre etc in the same way that some men shy away from changing a nappy. Neither is beyond learning, but culturally we still live in societies where crossing over the gender work divide still seems to cause some people an enormous amount of fear or apathy!

        • Very good point Vicki.

          • BarryMayor says:

            As I said elsewhere apparently, any woman who is not sick or elderly can change a tire. There is no need to flag down a man to do it, just as any man can fold laundry. However, those individuals may have been right that the person of the opposite gender was “better” at those tasks. Similar to women asking men to kill spiders, cut the grass, or take out the trash. Never have I heard feminists accuse women of sexism for demanding that men perform those tasks.

            Why not call out sexism even when it comes from women? Feminists seldom object to sexism that offers them an advantage. Somehow they find a way to justify and/or excuse it.

  3. BarryMayor says:

    “You’re seriously comparing “folding laundry” to “changing a tyre”? You think those two things are as difficult as each other? Get real.”

    Did you not read what the man said at the laundromat? He said she would be “better” at it than him, not that it was impossible for him to do it.

    Likewise, in the case I mentioned, the woman said that he would be “better” at changing the tire than her, not that she could not do it. Only an elderly and/or sick person cannot physically change a tire if they wish to. All you are doing is excusing and justifying sexism coming from feminists while castigating men for doing the same thing.

    “I will only agree that a woman flagging a man down to ask him to change her tyre is sexist if she ignored a number of women who she could have asked to help her instead. Likewise the laundry example is only sexist if the man in question didn’t ask men to help but specifically targeted the woman.”

    That was implied in both cases. But, as is often true within feminism, only “sexism” coming from men is considered objectionable and criticized. They almost always find a way to excuse and/or justify it coming from themselves.

    • vicki wharton says:

      Barry
      There is a great space for you to get together with other anti equal human rights people – it’s called Comment is Free on the Guardian website and is filled with people making up like for like situations to get equal rights campaigners to fence at. ‘Better’ at folding laundry and ‘better’ at changing tyres could easily be made less inflammatory by saying ‘more experienced at’ and then we could just discuss whether it’s a good idea for everyone that has laundry to fold their own and people that drive cars to have some willingness to change their own tyres where physically able to. End of.

      • BarryMayor says:

        I support equal rights, you oppose them. You are (as is common within feminism) arguing for superior rights for women and inferior rights for men.

        Feel free to name one anti-human EQUAL human rights position I have taken. Note the word EQUAL.

        I used the word “better” at because that was the word used in the article. Why didn’t you object to its use of “better”? Regardless, “more experienced” and “better” are not synonymous.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *