Deal between Strauss-Khan and maid’s lawyers could damage case
Summary of story from The Guardian, July 1, 2011
The prosecution’s case against Dominique Strauss-Khan is said to be close to collapse (see WVoN coverage).
The former International Monetary Fund head is accused of assaulting a hotel maid in New York in May, but there are reports that significant problems have emerged that could see the conditions of his bail-terms relaxed.
Two unnamed law-enforcement officials told The New York Times that there are ‘major holes’ in the case.
The speculation revolves around the prosecution’s alleged lack of confidence in the 32 year-old maid’s testimony as a witness – particularly her account of what happened to her in Strauss-Khan’s room at the Sofitel hotel in Manhattan on May 14.
An officer who is familiar with the case has been cited as saying that the issue is not with the rape accusation itself, but rather with questions about the alleged victim’s background that can potentially damage her credibility as a witness.
Lawyers in Strauss-Khan’s defence have suggested they have evidence calling into question the veracity of the accuser’s account. The nature of these doubts has not yet been revealed.
Lawyers for the maid were unavailable for comment last night.
When stories first emerged that Strauss-Kahn’s lawyers intended to argue the woman had consensual sex with Strauss-Kahn, her former lawyer Jeffrey Shapiro said:
“There was nothing about any aspect of this encounter between this young woman and the defendant which was remotely consensual or could be construed as consensual, either physical contact or sexual contact.”
A report in The New York Times has also suggested that police recorded a telephone conversation between the maid and a prison inmate on the day of the alleged rape in which the woman discussed possible financial benefits of a case against Strauss-Khan.
The newspaper also reported that an investigation found deposits made into the accuser’s bank account totalling $100,000 over two years, some of which came from the prison inmate, a convicted drug dealer.
The news comes after weeks of speculation about the strength of the accuser’s case.
Shapiro, and renowned civil rights lawyer, Normak Siegel, are no longer working on the case, and have declined to comment on their decision to leave.
Harvard law professor Alan Dershowitz told Newsweek earlier this month that he believed the woman’s lawyers were brokering a deal with Strauss-Khan’s lawyers and are working together.
Dershowitz said: “Clearly the defendant wants to avoid trial and wants to see if he can work out a deal that’s acceptable to him. And my sense is that the victim would like a big payday.
“Why does she want to make a deal now?
“Why not wait until the conviction, and then sue? [Because] the defendant doesn’t have much money. All the money is his wife’s money.
“And if you win a suit – let’s assume she wins a $10m judgment against him. She’s not going to collect it. He’ll go bankrupt.
“Whereas if she settles the case, the wife pays up.
“So the difference is between getting, say, a million right now from the wife, or $10m from the husband which the lawyer has to spend the rest of his life chasing,” he explained.
Making any such deal would threaten charges of obstruction of justice.
The maid has no power to stop the criminal case being brought by New York district attorney Cyrus Vance and she could be compelled to testify even if she decided not to co-operate, said Stuart Slotnick, a white collar crime expert.
















Why are so many people rushing to condemn DSK’s defense for smearing the alleged victim? Granted, that would most likely be part of their strategy if this went to trial, but we are nowhere near that point. As the story makes clear, it is the prosecution, not the defense, that may be getting cold feet. That’s not corruption in action. That’s professional responsibility. As a prosecutor, you simply cannot put someone on the stand if you believe that s/he will give false testimony. If nearly every experience you have with a witness leads you to believe this will be a problem, then what, precisely, are you *supposed* to do. The anonymous source put it best. This is a first-class mess.