Cinderella Ate My Daughter – and she’s still ravenous
The sexualisation of children is currently a hot topic in the UK, and Peggy Orenstein’s book, Cinderella Ate My Daughter, is a valuable addition to the debate.
Well-researched and extremely readable, it nonetheless left me, as the mother of a daughter, depressed about what the future holds for her.
But then, the picture that Orenstein paints – accurately in my view – is depressing.
She charts the progression of girls today from the almost-obligatory pink, pretty, passive ‘princess’ years – when girls have to be pretty for their prince to come – through to the ever-earlier ‘sexy’ years – when girls have to ‘perform’ sexuality for others’ consumption to be ‘hot’.
And there’s not much about the whole trajectory that doesn’t make me want to put my daughter up for adoption in Sweden.
As Orenstein delves into this world it becomes increasingly obvious that what is being sold to girls as ‘feminine’ rests almost entirely on the idea of physical beauty and ‘hotness’.
Visiting a trade Toy Fair, Orenstein despairs at the sea of pink toys before her, and the ‘singular lack of imagination about girls’ lives and interests,’ that the unending rows of make-up and fashion craft kits demonstrated.
As Orenstein notes, these things are not inherently bad in themselves – what little girl never played dress-up? Or boy for that matter.
But the ubiquity with which these ideas are now sold to girls, coupled with the almost complete lack of alternatives means that they have become effectively what it means to be a girl.
Without physical perfection – and without buying the necessary ‘equipment’ to attain that perfection – a girl will seem to drop out of her own gender with nowhere to land. Except become a boy maybe. Increasingly, there is no space in between.
‘As ‘pretty’ segues into ‘sexy’, Orenstein ignores knee-jerk reactions about whether it panders to paedophiles, and concentrates instead on how it affects the girls themselves. And she argues that it can cause them irreparable harm.
Girls learn to act desirable, but may never learn how to desire and therefore develop a healthy sexuality. ‘Sexiness’, becomes about how others perceive them and has nothing to do with sexuality as felt by the girls themselves.
Whether you accept this or not, one thing is undeniable and that is the driving force behind the new model of girlhood. At its heart, the book is an indictment of capitalism and how the consumer-driven society it produces harms the most vulnerable among us.
Orenstein notes that children are being delineated into ever smaller ‘categories’, listing as examples the surprisingly recent invention, by marketers, of the age stages ‘toddler’ and ‘tween’.
More childhood ‘stages’ means more products aimed at those specific stages. And so with gender.
Children of both sexes are separated out with increasing efficiency by marketing and media aimed specifically at exaggerating ‘difference’ between the two groups.
Why sell one product when, by telling parents that daughters and sons have entirely separate ‘play patterns’ you can sell two? If you can convince girls that their femininity is conferred by what they consume, so much the better. The sky’s the limit.
But what does this mean for our daughters? As Orenstein notes, the science doesn’t support it, but maybe these are just natural differences writ large. But gender segregated play is known to be damaging to both boys and girls.
Quoting child development experts, Orenstein points out that lack of inter-gender interaction and communication is ‘detrimental to relationships, psychological health and well-being’.
Girls and boys, it seems, should be encouraged to play together if they want to play together successfully as adults.
Given its very real potential to harm their children’s development, it’s ironic that parents appear to buy into this gender segregation so readily in order to protect their daughters from ‘growing up too quickly’.
The princesses peddled by Disney and others seem to embody the spirit of innocent childhood. Pretty and passive, they do nothing, wear nothing, say nothing that could be considered sexual. Relationships start and end with a kiss before marriage.
Real life ‘Disney princesses’ such as Hannah Montana are attractive to parents for the same reasons; they are safe and innocent. Or at least, until they grow up and start attempting to knowingly own their sexuality, inevitably by posing semi-naked in magazines.
These girls are then subject to the same slut-shaming mentality as all emerging women. Girls receive the message loud and clear: present ‘sexy’ and it’s all good. Be sexy, however, and you’re a slut.
I finished this book with the same feeling I had when I started it; an overwhelming sense of exhaustion.
As the mother of a girl, I was overcome with tiredness at the mere thought of trying to navigate the world my daughter is growing up in whilst attempting to raise a well-adjusted woman.
The entire books thrums with this essential dilemma: how do you teach a girl to resist and question this ‘girly’ culture, without making her an outsider to her own sex?
Orenstein, however, does manage to end the book on a somewhat hopeful note. There are things that parents can do to raise awareness in their daughters. Ultimately, though, these efforts have to be consciously made and rigorously followed to bear fruit.
With so many parents unaware or unaccepting that there is a problem, it seems unlikely that many will make that effort.

















Thank you for the review, Karen, this seems an interesting book.
I do wonder how my two girls are going to cope with being teenagers. They aren’t interested in the princess trappings at all (although they are voracious consumers, given the chance) but they will shortly enter that phase where everyone has a theory on how to be attractive to boys (who will have become, suddenly and inexplicably to them, attractive too) and I do wonder how to guide them through that without issuing instructions or absolute statements. Perhaps I shouldn’t read this book, I might become too depressed by it! 😉