UK government considers giving women right to know about violent men
Summary of story from The Telegraph, July 16, 2011
A campaign to give UK women the right to know if their partners have a history of violence was launched today.
Hazel Blears, former Home Office minister, is leading the proposal, Clare’s Law, named after Clare Wood who was murdered in 2009.
Ms Wood was unaware of her killer’s record of domestic violence when she met him on Facebook.
Ms Blears said: “By changing the law we can empower women so that they can take informed action about their relationship and give them the chance to protect themselves and prevent domestic abuse from happening before it begins.”
Home Secretary Theresa May and Louise Casey, the Government’s Victims Commissioner, are supporting the campaign.
Ms Casey said: “Our priority should not be protecting a perpetrator’s privacy at the expense of costing a woman’s life.”
Tory MP Robert Buckland, a member of the Commons Justice Committee, called for “strict controls” on any such system.
“We have to be certain this will not lead to fishing expeditions by women demanding confidential information about potential boyfriends without proper justification.
”You cannot have a carte blanche system where people can simply turn up at a police station, give the name of a boyfriend or potential boyfriend, and expect the police to open up all the files on him”, he said.
















We don’t need ‘all the files’, just the violence against women file. This could be groundbreaking in that men really would have to account for their behaviour and no longer would it be easy for them to hit a woman and then pretend it hadn’t happened. It might even propel some to seek treatment – how wonderful would that be.
I’m uneasy about this but I can’t quite explain why. It seems a good idea that people know a bit about each other if they are going to live their lives together… I don’t know. I think the unease is an emotional response rather than a logical one. Would it become commonplace for people to check up on each other at the police station, for instance, a bit like googling someone you’ve just met now? Does it imply mistrust or is it a sensible precaution? I wonder how many people will delude themselves that ‘he’s not like that any more’. 😐
Rationally, anything that encourages men to seek treatment has to be good. Is there good access to effective treatment?
Wait a minute I think I’ve got it – I am uneasy because this again places the onus of protecting women on the women and not on stopping the men being violent in the first place. We are again being encouraged to be fearful and mistrustful, and to not ‘ask for it’. That being said, sadly it would still be a useful resource. :-/
I hope it’s gender neutral given DV is generally found to be pretty evenly spread between the sexes in studies.
BarryMayor is that you? You look different somehow.
I am not BarryMayor, I post under my own identity thank you for the slander though.
As a central issue the law should be gender neutral by default, firstly it costs no more to do so, and secondly because doing so creates the first step towards equality: legal equality.
Studies have shown that domestic violence violence is a fairly gender neutral issue with both genders initiating at fairly even rates. Women tend to sustain more significant injuries (however are also more likely to use a weapon). There was a cite on either amptoons or noseriously recently about their being ~1000 female by male partner murders per year and ~300 male by female partner murders, its not an insignificant percentage.
Also from a point of fairness it is not fair to sweep male victims under the carpet no matter how few there are. Doing so presents a biased view which allows you to be called out for presenting it and undermines your arguments. Going gender neutral and acknowledging that both genders suffer from domestic violence is a simple way to strengthen your argument and gain support for actions.
My apologies for jumping to conclusions about your identity. It was out of line of me.
I agree that violence towards men, or violence by women, should not be ignored or belittled. That doesn’t serve any useful purpose and as you say it heaps more prejudice on people who are already having a hard time getting help (or even sympathy!).
No problem. I’m not a feminist by definition, and often the devils advocate(I believe in equality and giving people equal chances however I am not sure about equality of outcome or some of the damage feminism has done to men by sweeping their issues under the carpet. It’s not zero sum but both sides seem to play like it is).
Giving people hope is what we can do. If that means we never use the male side if the law then fine but if it’s not there thrn when one needs it he will either become an anonymous statistic or perhaps he ends up believing that people won’t support him and you lose a valuable supporter.
Does anyone one know if there is a violent persons register for Scotland? As Scotland has its own legal system.
Sipeki hadn’t heard of such a thing – I’m a Scot although I don’t live there now. However, when I went to check with Google, I learned that the sex offender register is actually the Violent and Sex Offender Register (ViSOR), so yes such a register already exists and presumably the change in the law proposed (for England and Wales only?) is that people other than the law enforcement authorities may access this information.
I know that the existing register is not without its problems – people on it can disappear, for instance, although the police are supposed to know their whereabouts.
Unless specifically Scots law the change won’t apply to Scotland.
Whether the information is accessible is a different kettle of fish.
So would Scotland see an influx of offenders I wonder? It seems a fairly easy thing for offenders on the list to fall off the radar at the moment so I don’t suppose they’d need to go that far.
Can you imagine some of the future news reports? ‘I know we told the deceased there was no file but that’s because the local constabulary hadn’t recorded the info right/passed it on/disclosed it/the offence wasn’t a recordable one for the purposes of this register, this is a tragic incident and measures are in place…’ The UK is supposed to be fond of bureaucracy and paperwork but we’re not doing so well with it lately.