The crimes that women commit against each other
Summary of story from The Independent, July 18, 2011
Journalist and author Yasmin Alibhai-Brown bemoans the fact that women are, sometimes, more sadistic than men and viciously hurt their own sex.
She points to revelations by the Human Trafficking Foundation that it is mainly women who are entrapping and forcing young, trusting girls from abroad into the most bestial forms of prostitution in the UK.
Until now, it was commonly believed that foreign male gangs were abducting girls or duping their families and then using rape and drugs to turn their victims into sex slaves.
There have been movies about the fearsome abductors and their grimy activities, some actual arrests and convictions. But until now, the extent of female involvement was unknown.
According to former Tory MP Anthony Steen and chairman of the foundation, trafficking is changing.
Instead of brutality, girls and young women are persuaded by older women to go abroad for a better life – false promises that are hard to resist for impoverished families in Romania, Albania and some African countries.
Steen gives examples of girls betrayed and sold off by their own mothers. Today, the Immigration Minister Damian Green will announce his policies to tackle this subterranean, wicked and lucrative trade. He is setting up a new, specialised agency to deal with a growing crime.
One hopes, says Alibhai-Brown, that he has been well briefed on the “wily women” who are now so actively involved.
In India, Pakistan, Japan, China and elsewhere there have always been women who prostituted their own daughters, or connived to capture innocent girls and groom them.
Sometimes the horrible business was turned into an art; in beautiful houses, women were taught courtly and sensual skills by old courtesans and the traditions passed through the generations. That practice still survives in some places but is veiled in secrecy and hypocrisy.
In the past five years, she says we have been forced to open our eyes here, as women, often in trusted positions, have been convicted of grotesque acts on babies, infants and teenagers.
The young American woman Jaycee Dugard, whose memoir has just been published, describes how she was taken, aged 11, from a street by Phillip Garrido and his wife Nancy, kept hidden and raped for years, being forced to give birth to her children with only the two monsters present (see WVoN story).
There are other examples of female collusion in heinous sex crimes, which destroy those comforting beliefs in motherly grace and feminine care.
Michele Elliott, a psychologist and director of the charity Kidscape, believes this is considered the “ultimate taboo”, something society does not want to think about:
“The possibility that the sexual abuse of a child can be perpetrated by women causes enormous controversy and distress. It is thought that even raising the possibility of women abusing children, detracts from the larger, more pervasive problem of male abuse.”
She gives examples of adults despoiled by their mums or other female relatives, who were disbelieved even by doctors.
And she berates feminists, with their neat critiques of male dominance, for being pathologically unable to deal with the fact that females are, sometimes, more sadistic than men and can and do viciously hurt their own sex.
Who dares within the sisterhood to revise the assumptions on which so much of that belief system rests? If we say that women must not be judged as harshly as men when they destroy those who are vulnerable, or that a woman must have the right to be as evil as a man, what kind of world is that?
She says she is coming round to the view that women shouldn’t behave as badly as bad men, but when they do, they should be judged more harshly.
Equality is essential, but morality is more fundamental; it has to be, surely.
















It’s not a new thing, this. I was reminded of ‘Doubly Deviant, Doubly Damned’, a book I used for bits of my undergraduate dissertation. It says that women *are* judged more harshly when they are discovered to be murderers (I’m remembering this, please WVoN commenters feel free to correct me if I’m mistaken) because they transgress twice. They transgress society’s rules against killing and they are female and so supposed to be caring and weaker, incapable of such things. Maybe that’s why I’m surprised that people are still surprised that women aren’t all angels… wasn’t Germaine Greer shocked in the 70s when she found out that the people performing FGM were women? (again, from memory)
I wonder why “even raising the possibility of women abusing children, detracts from the larger, more pervasive problem of male abuse”? Does it turn into a blame game instead of an exercise in trying to prevent such things, stop them?
I don’t know what to say about this article, really. How can Alibhai-Brown cover FGM for as long as she says she has and still be surprised that women can be evil to one another (and to men)? I clicked through to the article to see if I could discover why she wants women judged more harshly and for them to behave better in the first place but I’m none the wiser now.
Yes, I was very surprised to read Alibhai-Brown’s “take” on this. As you say, she’s well aware of FGM and the women who carry it out. It’s as if suddenly she’s decided that, as you put it, women “aren’t all angels”. But nobody has ever said they were.