Does sexuality always have to be a zero-sum game?
Harri Sutherland-Kay
WVoN co-editor
Earlier this week British journalist Ally Fogg wrote a very thought provoking comment piece in the Guardian.
The crux of his argument was that whilst “the mainstreaming of modern feminism” in western society has encouraged women’s sexual liberation, men are still seen as “simple creatures”, to the point whereby no one considers the positives of male sexuality.
His commentary is flawed in many ways.
Although Fogg makes clear from the outset that he is talking about white, western heterosexuality, he never defines what he means by “male sexuality” or “modern feminism”.
So we are left to engage with a collection of ideas.
Fogg uses the eroticisation of sexually active older women to illustrate his point. An eroticisation, he says, which is evidenced by the use of the terms “cougars” and “milfs”.
By contrast, according to Fogg, the male equivalents are “dirty old men”. This thought is furnished with a quotation from former British prime minister John Major who said:
“Unfortunately it’s not against the law to be an old lecher. Maybe it should be. Or at the very least you shouldn’t be rewarded with the highest office in the land.”
Major was talking about Dominique Strauss-Kahn, the former head of the International Monetary Fund who was charged recently with sexual assault.
“Cougar” and “milf” are derogatory, misogynistic terms and about as far away from erotic as you can get.
“Cougar” is used to refer to women who are “past their prime” who go out hunting for young male prey. The US television show “Cougar Town” is about as open and emancipatory as “Sex and the City”.
“Milf” is not much better. It’s an acronym standing for “mum I’d like to fuck” which came into popular usage following the 1999 US film “American Pie”.
These are not examples of how “the age-old proscriptions on female promiscuity have been largely broken down”.
But if they are direct descendants of modern feminism (as opposed to the backlash against feminism, as I’d always thought), we’re in much bigger trouble than I thought.
Moving beyond Fogg’s bizarre choice of descriptions and comparisons, some of what he says is worth engaging with.
He’s absolutely right when he says that: “(P)rejudices are rehearsed and reiterated by men and women alike, they reside in the intangible web of social norms, conventions and culture, but they can and must be challenged and changed.”
What he misses when he talks about norms and conventions in culture, is that the intangible webs hold implications for all genders.
Just think, for a moment, about the forums within which perceptions of sexuality have been challenged, because they have varied hugely between men and women.
It is really thanks to women’s consciousness-raising groups in the 1960s that women were able to collectively come together and share their stories.
It was through sharing and learning that women were able to feel a sense of entitlement (sexual, social and political), previously only afforded to white men.
It is only very recently that women have been allowed to be seen to have a sex life. However the media has trapped ideas of beauty, sex and desire, it has fetishised them and reproduced them with the help of capitalism and the mass-market.
The balance of power, in reality, has barely shifted. You only need to glance at advertising campaigns to see this.
Feminism, meanwhile, has moved into the academy. It is a subject of political study, of critical engagement. There are positive and negative aspects to this.
We have a much better historical understanding of what feminism is and what feminism means, but it is easy to remove the topic from our daily lives when surely it is essential to feminism that it is lived, or else it isn’t ours and it loses its meaning.
The definition of feminism that I use comes from bell hooks, who writes: “Simply put, feminism is a movement to end sexism, sexist exploitation, and oppression.”
I could write a whole book on why I like this definition of feminism so much, but suffice to say it is simple, accurate and useful and it doesn’t position men against women. But it does necessitate the identification of patriarchy.
It would be foolish to allow the discourse on gender and sexuality to degenerate into a battle of the sexes in which the fight for a fair, free and diverse desire mutates into a zero-sum game. In that instance, nobody gains anything.
For me, it is that which needs to change above all else.
Our public dialogue on sex and sexuality needs to broaden and become more inclusive. This means talking about masculine and feminine sexualities and moving forward.
One of my favourite quotations is from Nadia C’s “Vanguard of the Sexual Revolution” and I think it is essential to consider when talking about women and men and sex.
She writes: “Because we have so little honest, intimate, beautifully dangerous sex that they can sell us flat images of it instead. Because we spend so much more time contemplating these representations than having sex that when we do sleep together, it is more a meeting of roles than of individuals.”
Or, as a friend of mine said earlier when I was speaking to him about Fogg’s article: “The essential comedy of the body must be reborn!”

















I think one of the problems with defining male sexuality, or masculinity is that though explorations of it exist, they haven’t quite entered the academy in the same that texts on female sexuality have.
The feminist movement has the blessing and the curse of being able to carve a very definite territory within the world of theory. It’s easy to go through my bookshelf and say this, this, this, this and this is a feminist text.
When it comes to theory on masculinity, locating texts under that umbrella isn’t quite so easy. I don’t think it was until recently that males even suspected they needed to be able to define their work as being on male sexuality.
As a result, there are actually a lot of fictional works out there that deal with masculine sexual identities, but which lack both that categorisation and the theory to reinforce them.
In some of the best received scenarios these books have simply been overlooked: Carver’s “What we talk about when we talk about love”, Fleming’s “Casino Royale”, Chandler’s “Farewell, My Lovely”, Mann’s “Death in Venice”, Kureishi’s “Something to Tell You”.
In the worst cases attempts to discuss “honest, intimate, beautifully dangerous sex” have been met with hostility from both genders. Their authors have been stigmatised, ostracised and insulted, while the works have often beein branded as pornographic despite challenging pornography: Bataille’s “Story of the Eye”, Burgess’s “A Clockwork Orange”, Ballard’s “Crash”, Nabokov’s “Lolita”, even Salinger’s “Catcher in the Rye”.
The strong negative critical reaction to these works has the double effect of both discouraging male conversation and obscuring the actual arguments of the books.
That response, which Fogg seems to have simplified down to an issue of double-standards and hypocrisy (without actually using either of those two terms), needs to be stripped away or disregarded in order to approach these discourses with as few prejudices as possible.
I don’t think that the way of approaching the issue is to define male sexuality as a strict genre. I don’t like classifying Dorothy Allison, Tony Morrison, Doris Lessing, Jean Rhys or Angela Carter as just being novelists who write about female sexuality.
Their novels are far too complex for such a simplification and in applying those labels to both genders we only encourage a very reactive, angry discourse.
Male sexuality isn’t signposted. As Fogg said it is “diverse”, “complex”, “wonderful”, “base”, “coarse” and “animalistic”. I think Fogg’s difficulty in defining sexuality lay in its very nature.
Sexuality doesn’t want to be nailed down and it shouldn’t. Perhaps the desire to neatly categorise it is what’s stopping the inclusive broadening of public dialogue.
For me, we need to take the categorisation away, as well as the culture of attacking anything that doesn’t depict conventional, contemporary, pre-rehearsed sexual roles.
If we do that then we’ll find that the male monologues have been there, and have always been there, relatively unengaged.
If we ignore them though we’ll be trapped in daft arguments that try to equate cougars to lechers for ever more.