Translator errors threatened woman’s refugee hearing
Summary of story from the National Post, dosage July 19, 2011
A woman claiming political persecution was on the verge of deportation to her native Kenya — after her testimony at a refugee hearing was deemed incoherent and evasive — when it was revealed a Swahili translator had “butchered” what she was saying.
Last week, a Federal Court of Canada judge gave the woman another chance to state her claim — clearly, this time.
That such potentially grave consequences stem from a translator deemed “incompetent” by other language specialists, and who has been previously removed for similar problems, highlights “systemic” problems with the Immigration and Refugee Board (IRB), critics say.
Refugee law experts decry the IRB’s translation services as a “crisis” leading to injustice for legitimate refugees, delays in hearings and costly litigation.
“This is a big issue that has been going on for years and needs to be addressed,” said Raoul Boulakia, the woman’s Toronto lawyer and former president of the Refugee Lawyers’ Association.
The case involves Samirah Mohamed Neheid, 50, and her 22-year-old daughter, who claimed refugee protection because her son had worked for a political opposition group in Kenya.
“The translator was clearly not interpreting competently,” said Mr Boulakia. “Throughout the hearing he was butchering everything, completely missing what was being said. He was saying things in English that were gibberish.”
The interpreter failed to relay portions of questions and answers, provided inaccurate translations of what was said and spoke broken English and poor Swahili, court documents say.
The woman testified that her son went to political rallies and put up opposition posters, which the interpreter translated as: “Sometimes he come home with postage.”
The adjudicator admonished Ms Neheid for being “evasive and at times incoherent” and expressed frustration with her perceived lack of co-operation. When her lawyer raised the problem, the adjudicator said that because none of them spoke Swahili it could not be said errors were being made.
The woman’s daughter, who was at the hearing and speaks a little English, also voiced concern but was told to be quiet by the adjudicator.
Ms Neheid’s refugee claim was denied and she and her daughter were ordered back to Kenya.
Two other Swahili translators dismissed the interpreter as incompetent in sworn statements filed in court.
At the original hearing, the interpreter was even told to ask Ms Neheid about the quality of his interpretation. She said she did not believe he was translating properly, which the interpreter translated as: “I want to know, to understanding very well, what he asks this guy.”
Federal Court Justice Michael Phelan overturned the IRB’s decision, saying there were serious errors in the translation that “led to adverse credibility findings.”
“The board was clearly frustrated by what they heard through the interpreter. The applicant and her daughter were likewise frustrated and perplexed by the translation and the board’s reaction,” Justice Phelan ruled.
“The court finds that there was a breach of fairness by reason of unreasonable translation.”
The same interpreter had been ejected from another refugee hearing over complaints of incompetence, the Federal Court was told.
















Why was the assumption made that the person pleading the case was talking gibberish rather than the person translating? :-/