subscribe: Posts | Comments

Goldman Sachs uses Wal-Mart ruling to fight sex bias case

1 comment

Summary of story from Reuters, July 22, 2011

Investment bank Goldman Sachs has said that a recent landmark decision throwing out a class-action lawsuit against Wal-Mart (see WVoN coverage) means it should not face a wide-ranging case accusing it of systematic bias against women.

In court papers, the bank argued that the three women who sued it last year have highly individual claims that cannot be readily applied to a wider class of plaintiffs.

The plaintiffs allege that Goldman underpays women and promotes them less often than men.  The women are seeking back pay, changes to compensation and promotion practices, punitive damages and attorneys’ fees.

Last month, the US Supreme Court said a gender bias case against Wal-Mart on behalf of a group believed to exceed 1.5 million workers could not proceed because the plaintiffs’ claims did not have enough in common to sue as a group.

Goldman’s lawyers have argued that, “The (Wal-Mart) holding has powerful relevance here.

“The charge does not mention or allege any class-wide problem common to any ‘similarly-situated women’  the plaintiff seeks to represent.

“It does not set forth even one factual contention supposedly common to her and anyone else,” Goldman’s lawyers wrote.

The proposed class action seeks to represent “similarly situated” current and former female associates, vice presidents and managing directors employed by the company.

Men at the company “are viewed more favorably, receive more compensation, and are more likely to be promoted,” the plaintiffs wrote.

The Wal-Mart ruling is expected to have a significant impact on sex discrimination class-actions, because it makes it harder to win certification of large groups of plaintiffs.

The Wal-Mart decision asserted that “vague allegations of class-wide discrimination” are not enough to support a sex bias class action lawsuit, Goldman’s attorneys wrote in Thursday’s filing.

A grant of class-action status can result in larger awards and make it easier for people who otherwise could not sue on their own to recover.

  1. BarryMayor says:

    I wonder if they are taking ALL factors into consideration. For example, do they consider the fact that women recieve 16 weeks of parental leave whereas men get only 4 weeks? (BTW, how is that equal work for equal pay? Answer: it’s not)

    And, if there are muliple births, is it reasonable to expect a mother and a father to advance at the same rate if he is doing 3 more months of work than she does?

    After the birth of children, were the men and women in question equally career focused, spending the same amount of time and mental focus at and one work? Does the suit take those things into consideration?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *