Diane Arbus, a photographer who provoked shame and awe
Summary of story from the Guardian, July 26, 2011
Diane Arbus’s work was always going to be controversial. It’s been 40 years since her suicide and her legacy of grotesque portraiture continues to provoke and divide.
In the Guardian, Sean O’Hagan reconsiders the body of work she left behind.
Arbus undoubtedly felt at home among the outsiders she photographed, she also experienced a frisson of guilty pleasure when photographing them.
“There’s some thrill in going to a sideshow,” she once confessed of her nocturnal visits to the circus tents of Coney Island, where performers were still earning a living in the 1960s.
“I felt a mixture of shame and awe.”
Her works make us question not just her motives for looking at what the critic Susan Sontag – with typical hauteur – called: “People who are pathetic, pitiable, as well as repulsive”, but also our own.
In perhaps the most angry essay in her book On Photography, Sontag insists that Arbus’s gaze is “based on distance, on privilege, on a feeling that what the viewer is asked to look at is really other”.
The “other” is not what it used to be. We live in a time when it is ubiquitous, whether in voyeuristic TV shows about “embarrassing bodies” or documentaries about sexual exhibitionists or conjoined twins.
Nevertheless, Arbus’s black-and-white portraits – particularly of those with mental disabilities or physical abnormalities – retain their power to unsettle and disturb.
Arbus may have felt an enormous empathy with the people she photographed, but she was not one of them, however much she identified with their outsider status.
She had her own troubles, but they were of a different order.
The work she left behind remains powerful not just because of its dark formal beauty or its stark vision, but because it asks questions of the viewer about the limits of looking.
When we look at an Arbus photograph, we cannot help feeling that we are intruders or voyeurs, even though her subjects are tied to a time and place that has all but vanished.
A sense of complicity – hers and ours – lies at the very heart of her power. Her images hold us in their sway even when our better instincts tell us to look away.
Perhaps her greatest gift is that she understood that conflict instinctively, and did more than anyone to exploit it artistically.











