subscribe: Posts | Comments

Should Google+ ban pseudonyms?

6 comments

Summary of story from Bug Girl’s blog, July 24, 2011

Google’s new social media effort has a “no pseudonyms” policy, prompting some members of the online community to back a petition aiming to change it.

Online enthusiast, “Bug Girl”, argues that the policy “puts people at risk and silences their voices in this new online forum. Not because we have misbehaved, but because our privacy is important and we won’t give it up”.

Google+ has been a trending topic since it was unveiled on 1 July, attracting 20 million unique visitors in the three weeks following, according to the Wall Street Journal.

The service provides social tools helping users categorise online friends, create sharing networks and interactively chat or video conference online.

But demanding real names to use the service has drawn criticism from users who have been kicked out because they write under a pseudonym.

Geek Feminism Wiki expresses the following concerns:

The cost to these people {of denying pseudonym use} can be vast, including:

  • harassment, both online and offline
  • discrimination in employment, provision of services, etc.
  • actual physical danger of bullying, hate crime, etc.
  • arrest, imprisonment, or execution in some jurisdictions
  • economic harm such as job loss, loss of professional reputation, etc.
  • social costs of not being able to interact with friends and colleagues

Bug Girl explains that her reasons have to do with a potential legal backlash as a civil servant, her health condition (she has epilepsy) and her status as a rape survivor.

WVoN comment: Supporters in the comments section of Bug Girl’s blog point out that allowing pseudonyms could open Google to litigation. After all, the exact people that might cause harm are likely to use a pseudonym.

However, although “Bug Girl” may be an obvious fake name, other users with more real sounding names have not been kicked out of their accounts.

So it seems those with an existing audience for their pseudonym and  with legitimate reasons for using it are getting the boot. Whether or not Google responds to this petition remains to be seen, but certainly its supporters make some compelling arguments.

  1. Jane Osmond says:

    This is interesting – on the one hand I am all for real names and standing by comments, but on the other am conscious that people, especially women do get targeted by trolls, and sometimes this is dangerous – see Sady Doyle, who writes about the problems females on the internet routinely suffer and she highlights the shocking case of Kathy Sierra (http://tigerbeatdown.com/2011/01/06/why-i-didnt-delete-tiger-beatdown/)

    This is also an interesting take on the subject: http://geekfeminism.org/2011/01/06/quick-hit-getting-too-close-to-power/

  2. 2ndnin says:

    I think the solution is to have accounts flagged as ‘pseudo’ or similar such that people are aware that pseudoname accounts exist and can choose their level of privacy to real and virtual people individually. Google should get some form of legal support for that in that they have informed people that x is not backed by a real verifiable account and so content is at owner / readers own risk.

    Being able to further separate real and virtual is a good idea however it would be nice to know an account is backed by a real person.

    • Jane Osmond says:

      Hmm – yes, that is something to think about.

    • I kind of like the ‘pseudo’ account tag idea but I don’t think it says anything about a person other than they aren’t posting under their own name. Content it always read at the readers risk surely? I don’t know if using a pseudonym is an indicator for trolling or other fakery.

      • 2ndnin says:

        Yes but google can be held responsible or forced to give out contact information on people posting on it’s sites. A pseudo-only tag would let people know the poster can only be tagged by their IP address and are not tied to a real person. It’s a legal work around for people suing them likely.

        The other is a permanent altid, let google or whatever manage your online id.

        • That sounds scary.(permanent altid managed by someone else)

          Surely service providers can already be compelled to track someone down by IP etc.? I’m not all that techy, I remember a couple of news items about that sort of thing though.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *