subscribe: Posts | Comments

Nicaraguan Supreme Court branded rape a “crime of passion”

0 comments

Summary of story from IPS News, July 25 2011

Nicaraguan’s Supreme Court ruled last week that the rape of a young woman was a “crime of passion” in a verdict that many suspect has political overtones.

It then reduced the prison sentence of Farinton Reyes from eight to four years for the rape of 23-year-old Fátima Hernández.

It ruled that his sexual assault was not violent and was committed “in a fit of passion under the influence of alcohol,” and with “permissive cooperation” by the victim, because she had had a few beers with him.

It ordered that Reyes, who had spent 18 months in jail on remand, should be released on the grounds that there were mitigating factors such as no criminal record, good behaviour, and lack of malicious premeditation.

The ruling cannot be appealed in any national court.

Women’s organisations and political analysts have said that it was politically motivated, because Reyes is a member of the ruling Sandinista National Liberation Front, as is his mother, Xiomara Larios, a famous former athlete with connections in the government.

Paradoxically, less than a month ago, the Supreme Court launched with great pomp a campaign with the slogan “Woman, You Are Not Alone”, which aims to combat violence against women.

“There is no excuse. It is a bad precedent for Nicaraguan justice that such a serious crime against a woman should be viewed by the Supreme Court as a lesser case, and that it would let a rapist off the hook,” Juana Jiménez, a member of the Autonomous Women’s Movement, one of the organisations that held a protest vigil against the verdict, told IPS.

Vilma Núñez, head of the non-governmental Nicaraguan Human Rights Centre, told IPS that the Supreme Court verdict violated basic principles that favour the victim over the aggressor, especially since the fact of the rape was proved.

“There is a victim, an assailant, a crime, a sentence, evidence, witnesses and proof, but in the Court’s own judgment, it decided the criminal should go free, and that the victim was to some extent responsible for allowing the crime to happen. This is unheard of,” said Núñez.

In her view, establishing the precedent of a “cooperative victim” is “extremely serious” for Nicaraguan women suffering sexual attack, as is the view taken by the Supreme Court that a “fit of passion”, producing a state of “fury” and sexual “excitement”, constitutes extenuating circumstances for rape.

The Reyes’ verdict was signed by 15 of the 16 Supreme Court justices. The dissenting vote was from Judge Yadira Centeno, who in her minority opinion said the reduction of the sentence was “unlawful.”

Hernandez, the rape victim, who had been on a 25-day hunger strike in order to draw attention to her plight, has been admitted to the hospital. Her father said that, despite being frail, she is “strong and dignified and will continue to demand justice.”

Prior to the verdict being issued, she had said that, if the ruling went against her, she would take her case to the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights to begin proceedings that could put the state of Nicaragua in the dock before the Inter-American Court of Human Rights.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *