Strauss-Kahn accused, but maid’s word on trial
Summary of story from The Guardian, July 27, 2011
Guardian commentator Zoe Williams argues that, in the Strauss-Kahn affair, the concept of ‘innocent until proven guilty’ should apply to the accuser as well as the accused.
She points out that while presumed innocence has been granted to Strauss-Kahn, the same cannot be said for his accuser.
Nafissatou Diallo, the woman who accused Strauss-Kahn of attempted rape, has given interviews to ABC News and Newsweek to argue her case publicly (see WVoN story).
She says she has gone public because her credibility has been called into question by Strauss-Kahn’s lawyers and the US media.
The details that have supposedly led to the collapse of her case, which are sketchy at best, are her immigration status, a conversation she had with a drug dealer who may have been her boyfriend, and her later changing the order of events in her report of the alleged attack.
Williams points out that a person’s immigration status is irrelevant to whether they have been sexually assaulted or not.
Secondly, she reports that the conversation with the drug dealer, in which she is alleged to have made compromising remarks, has not yet been translated properly.
About the final point, that Diallo initially said she had gone into a corridor to collect herself when it later transpired that she had in fact gone into another room, Williams questions how one can speculate on the actions of an honest person immediately after a sexual assault.
However, these points have been held up as evidence of her untrustworthiness and lack of credibility. Any past crime committed by the accuser, even if unrelated to the claim at hand, is enough to ‘torpedo’ their credibility.
Strauss-Kahn’s past misdemeanours, on the other hand, are not used to dent his word. A case is currently being brought against him in France for the same offence by Tristane Banon (see WVoN coverage).
Diallo said when she found out who DSK was she was frightened for her life: if it had happened in Guinea, with “a powerful man like that”, she would have been killed.
In the brave western way, says Williams, nobody has to silence a complainant so crudely. Incredulity is enough.











