subscribe: Posts | Comments

Documentary sheds light on Berlin ‘honour’ killing

2 comments

Summary of story from Der Spiegel, July 28, 2011

A new German documentary aims to reconstruct the story of Hatun Sürücü, who died in an ‘honour’  killing in 2005, and chart the subsequent impact on the family.

Hatun’s brother, Ayhan, shot his sister in the head three times as she waited at a bus stop in Berlin.

The new documentary includes an interview with him in prison, during which he says he committed “the worst mistake” of his life but claims that he ” didn’t know anything else at the time”.

The Sürücü’ family, ethnic Kurds whose strongly-held notions of ‘correct’ female behaviour conflicted with those of the west, moved to Germany from Turkey in the 1970s.

According to Ayhan, the night she was murdered Hatun had said “I’ll sleep with anyone I want.” For her father (who has since died) and brothers this was sufficient grounds for ending her life.

Hatun, 23, didn’t know Ayhan was armed that night. But she had known she was in danger because of her lifestyle choices. Much earlier, she had written a letter about her family troubles to the youth welfare office asking for help.

Although she had already escaped from the restrictions of life with her family, she maintained some contact with them, including with Ayhan, whom she trusted.

When Hatun had turned 15, her father had pulled her out of a well-integrated high school in Berlin because she was too rebellious. He sent her to Turkey, where she was married to a cousin.

She returned in 1999 – legally divorced, but pregnant with her son Can. For a while she lived with her parents and tried to raise the boy with her brothers and sisters in a crowded, four-bedroom Berlin apartment.

But after several months, she left. She stopped wearing a headscarf, entered the German welfare system, began wearing makeup and trained as an electrician in another neighborhood.

Ayhan’s girlfriend, Melek, was a witness during the murder trial. She claimed Ayhan’s two older brothers, Alpaslan and Mutlu, procured the murder weapon and hammered out the plan.

Alpaslan and Mutlu are now sought for a new trial in Berlin with an international arrest warrant. Melek has gone underground because of perceived danger from the two other Sürücü brothers, who are still at large.

“As long as they don’t pay (for the crime),” she says in the film, “I won’t have any peace.”

Mutlu appears in the documentary, despite being wanted by the German police. He is a radicalized Muslim, living in Turkey from where he cannot be extradited.

What did his sister do to deserve her own death? “The lifestyle change,” he says. “Why does a woman need to dress up so prettily? Why does she need to go out on the town? To attract men.”

He now claims to disapprove of the crime, though the Berlin court wants to consider evidence that he was also involved.

He says vigilantism is forbidden by Islamic law. “But fornication is too,” he adds. He says he’s praying for his sister. “I want Allah to forgive her sins”.

  1. How often are men punished for fornication? Do their brothers gun them down in the streets?

  2. BarryMayor says:

    No, but they should. Really, they shouldn’t gun down either but if they’re going to do it to one, why should the males be excluded? That shows that moral purity is not their aim; it’s domination of women. Otherwise, the same standards would apply to men.

    Along those same lines (but far, far less extreme), why does Islam require women to cover themselves in modesty if men aren’t required to do so? Men and women both can commit fornication or adultery.

    Likewise, here in the west we have a similar legal restriction that is unfair and discriminatory: if women must cover their chest (breast), so should men. I disagree with double standards, whether they emanate from a culture, religion, movement (e.g. feminism) or government. I am not anti-religion, anti-government, or anti-culture unless they mistreat people and/or treat them unfairly.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *