Switzerland’s influx of foreign prostitutes forces a rethink on sex law
Summary of story from the Independent, August 2, 2011
A public backlash is brewing as Switzerland opens its borders to more foreign workers – in turn bringing more sex workers – forcing a radical re-think of some of the most liberal prostitution laws in Europe.
Europeans wanting to work in Switzerland need only present themselves to the authorities with proof of health insurance, and undergo a brief interview with police – providing they are from a country signed up to the Free Movement of Persons Agreement.
This includes sex workers, who can be granted permission to work on the streets, in brothels or massage parlours across Switzerland for 90 days.
It is the addition of poorer east European countries – in particular Hungary and Romania – to the agreement that has brought a flood of new sex workers crossing the boarder to sell their bodies in one of the richest cities in the world.
This has caused a public backlash, forcing a rethink of Switzerland’s liberal laws on sex workers.
The country’s largest city, Zurich, is addressing the problem by proposing a ‘drive-through sex park’, which is part of an overhaul that includes reducing the number of areas in the city where prostitutes can legally work from 11 to three.
Based on a similar model in Germany, customers will pull off the road and into a compound where they are able to view and choose their preferred prostitute. They will then enter one of about 10 ‘sex boxes’ complete with privacy walls and a security alarm.
The proposal is currently before the city parliament. Claudia Nielsen, Zurich’s city councillor for health and environment, says she is confident that this will be passed and enacted by January 2012.
City authorities have even found an area where the residents are unlikely to complain – the drive-through brothel backs directly on to a temporary housing block where asylum-seekers live as they wait to have their applications processed.
One plank of the plan – the police interviews for prospective sex workers – has already been rushed through and came into effect in June.
Critics of the plan are concerned that the new policies have been rushed through to try to reduce the number of sex workers, without adequate discussions about the possible negatives.
Doro Winkler, who works for FIZ, an advocacy group for migrant women, worries that some sex workers may be forced into the hands of exploitative pimps if they do not pass the police interview.
While advocacy groups working with the prostitutes fear that the policies may drive more women underground, the city insists they are necessary to both protect the women and calm public anger over the social annoyances that curb crawlers bring.
The women working in Zurich’s red light area, the Sihlquai, are said to be generally happy about any proposals that will protect them from violent clients.
“It’s a big problem that there are many aggressive clients”, said one Hungarian prostitute.
Her friend said: “It’s got to be better than them killing us here on the Sihlquai.”











