subscribe: Posts | Comments

Diversity fail for Amnesty TV

0 comments

Jane Osmond
WVoN co-editor

A powerful blog post by Bidisha on 24 July excoriated Amnesty International for the complete lack of diversity on its Amnesty TV production team (see WVoN story).

Basically the team is composed of 11 white men, and Bidisha was so infuriated by this that she asked Amnesty’s media team for a comment.

She then received information on which episodes feature women’s issues, rather than a comment that directly addressed the huge diversity fail on the production team.

Feeling equally infuriated, I emailed the Amnesty TV press office for a comment, asking them specifically for a quote that addressed the decision to choose 11 white men for the production team and received this reply:

Amnesty International UK is grateful for the feedback it has received about the gender balance in the production team for Amnesty TV.

We have a great team involved in the initial creation and launch of Amnesty TV and we’re looking forward to working with many other talented people in the future.

In terms of content, highlighting human rights issues that specifically affect women and girls or impact on them in a disproportionate way is a key aspect of Amnesty TV’s remit.

For example, we have a film on a Palestinian women’s football team, we are following three female candidates in the forthcoming Egyptian elections (Amnesty’s key message for these elections is equal participation for women), and we are focusing on negotiations with the Taliban in Afghanistan and the effect it may have on women’s rights, specifically around education.

Best wishes [Media unit, Amnesty International UK]

As you can see, I also received a reply that completely body-swerves the crucial question of the production team’s ‘hideously white’ composition. (Thank you Greg Dyke for this phrase – it really is one of my favourites).

Harri, the co-editor and author of the original WVoN article commented that she would not change Bidisha’s words, because she is, well, Bidisha:  I also cannot expect to improve upon Bidisha’s words to express how I feel about this reply, so have copied her response below.

Meanwhile, we can only hope that the output of a group of white men whose ‘collective background [is] in puerile, sniggering light entertainment’ attracts the kinds of comments that will make Amnesty TV think more deeply about the composition of its production team in future.

Hi there and thanks for your email, which I appreciate, which is civil and clear and free of the victim-blaming that greets so many of these ‘where are the women’ articles that I and many other women have to write, week in, week out, whether they are about charity TV or hollywood films, newspaper sports coverage, business, religion, book prizes or political representation. I am going to put your email, and this response of mine, at the bottom of the article. I will not communicate with you after this.

The items you mention for future episodes look excellent. They are lively, topical and reflect the urgency of women’s situation as well as our proactiveness in challenging it. You represent women as heroic freedom fighters, tough advocates, strong victims, fearless campaigners, valiant survivors, We are!

But women are not just oppression-fighters, victims or survivors. Women want to have good lives, to be on the inside, to enjoy success, inclusion, relaxation, power, influence, creativity.

My article is not about the content of Amnesty TV, it is about the make-up of the production team.11 white men with a comedy background and 0 women is not okay on any show and certainly not on a show about global human rights.

You have been given the power to assemble a team and you have chosen 10 other white men and no women. You are sending the message that you believe women are not good enough to participate behind the scenes in your project, that you are not interested in working closely with women as equals and that women do not deserve to share power with you.

When the project is over, you and your 10 white male chums will benefit for a long time in your careers and you will go on to help each other, which is what men’s clubs do and indeed what you have already done.

Women globally will still be fighting abuse and oppression with no money, resources or power. They will be dependent on men-only clubs like yours to give them coverage. More privileged women in the UK who wish to have similar jobs to yours will be excluded, maybe by you.

You close your email by saying, “Best of luck with everything.” In choosing to put together a production team of 11 white men and 0 women on a global human rights TV project you have made it clear that any woman and any non-white person of either sex who wished to be involved in producing Amnesty TV as part of its central team would need a lot more than luck.

Next time you are given an opportunity to share power, do not choose to share it with 10 other white men only and then be forced to write squirming emails to strangers.

Bidisha

Quite.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *