Finance, feminism and the fair sex
Comment on and summary of story in Daily Mail, August 8, 2011
The Daily Mail in an annoyingly misleading and anti-feminist tirade today brands women as “hopeless with money.”
The first half of the article (which is let’s face it the bit most people read) blames the fair sex’s financial ‘myopia’ on bad shopping habits, waiting for ‘Prince Charming’ (!) and unwillingness to get to grips with the ‘tiresome’ world of finance.
There’s even a new term for such saddos: “Cinderella Singletons”.
Carry on fair reader though and there follows some sound (if a little patronising) financial advice from Savvywomen’s, Sarah Pennells; Sheconomics’ co-author, Professor Karen Pine and Saga’s Ros Altmann.
Get a pension; get an IFA; get a grip on your finances ‘Girls’ is the general message.
My advice to them?: Okay…we hear you… but how about Getting a Life first?
















My experience is that people are either good with money or bad with money and this is a gender neutral trait.
I agree, Jane – I’m bad with money and I know it, but then so is my husband. For every couple I know where the man keeps hold of the finances I know a couple where the woman knows where every penny is. Trust the Mail to write something biased and basically untrue.
Looking at the crashingly bad state of the economy due to largely male financial dishonesty – which is what ‘misselling’ of sub prime financial products actually is in real language – I would have thought the Mail should keep its big bigotted mouth shut. The words pot kettle and black come to mind.
I agree 🙂
The people in these roles are a tiny fraction of the populace. Blaming MEN for the actions of some Men is rather disingenuous.
I’m not. The UK’s financial institutions and boards who set the corporate direction are almost exclusively male and brought up in a certain cultural climate which celebrates ‘getting away with it’ as one lad’s mag’s banner proclaims. I do not think it is disingenuous to draw the conclusion that if you have a couple of generations of boys who have been brought up to ‘get away with it’ and you put them in charge of financial institutions, Governments, the police and the media that sooner or later the shit will hit the fan – as I believe we are currently experiencing with the problems with corruption of values in the media, MPs, the police and the banks. My comment about male fiscal irresponsibility was simply drawing the point in relation to the Mail’s article about female fiscal ineptness but I never said all men, that was simply your interpretation of my words.
I agree. 🙂
Vicki. You didn’t blame all men anywhere in your post, you said the people to blame were mostly men, and they were and still are. I agree with Jane, gendered financial traits have always seemed like immense hogwash to me. Hive behaviour is very apparent though. The biggest problems came not from people trying to outdo each other but rather copying each other. Individual responsibility for risk assessment is lost amid a rush to join in. If everyone is doing it, it must be a good idea. That’s how the markets work and how the rating agencies have always worked.
2ndnin, Will you be registering your distaste for generalisations at the Mail also, in response to this lazy old fashioned tripe?
If it might do any good I would, alas the daily fail is a lost cause pretty much. Perhaps that’s the wrong attitude but I would rather try and change those willing to listen than rant at those who will never care.
Oddly enough earlier on today it was noted that the Mail appeared to be giving coverage to the EDL/Police clashes in London* when the rest of the UK press have been rather reticent about it. Imagine my surprise.
*I think it was London, anyway. Apologies if I have remembered the wrong rioting city. 😐
How do i get to read the comments?
Just go to the site and pick whichever story you’re interested in – any comments will be at the bottom of it. Thanks.