We were frightened for a day: many youngsters live in fear
Summary of story from ABC.net.au, August 11, 2011
A British youth worker says the country’s social system needs to shoulder some of the blame for the riots that erupted on the streets of London.
Camila Batmanghelidjh, who has spent decades working with poor and disenfranchised youth, says there are social factors underlying the violence that cannot be ignored.
Ms Batmanghelidjh, who founded charities The Place To Be and Kids Company, says many disadvantaged young Britons lack the social structures to improve their lives.
“Eighty-four per cent of the young people that arrive at Kids Company arrive homeless, and 73 per cent are not even registered with a GP.”
“Large numbers of these people don’t even have a birth certificate and because of that they can’t access benefits.”
“So the normal structures around these people have been eroded and they experience the state as constantly chasing them down for debts, taking them to court, threatening them with various things.
“But they don’t see the state extending a helping hand to actually help them through their difficulties.”
Ms Batmanghelidjh says that as a result, “violence becomes the currency of survival” and many neighbourhoods are propped up by the drug trade.
And the divide between the rich and the poor exacerbates the problem.
Responding to remarks that the rioters had frightened people, Ms Batmanghelidjh says many British youths have lived with a feeling of fear for their entire lives.
“This happened to the public for a few days. But many of these children are chronically frightened – they get attacked in their own homes, they get attacked on the estates,” she said.
And, she points out, “their conditions of fright have been chronically ignored”.
















Yes, Camila is one of my heroes – she really nails the problem every time ‘feral youth’ get the blame for everything.
Valid points. Nobody seems to be talking about fear. The mob mentality for a brief moment creates a sense of bravado, but most young people live with a sense of fear every day of their lives. They either fear the police, security guards or shopkeepers that eye them suspiciously, but most of all they live in fear of one another. Some openly embrace the ‘gansta’ lifestyle, whilst others merely stick together in groups, but the crime statistics show that if your male and under 25 you are far more likely to be a victim of violent crime.
Housing,property prices, and middle class angst about school catchment areas divide the haves and the have-nots from the day they were born. The have-nots are not stupid, they see corrupt elites getting away with crime, and they have shown that they can do the same.
The liberals have flocked to the cause of ‘we’re all in this together’ waving their brooms, and the ignorant have flocked to the pub for some dutch courage and casual racism only to emerge four hours later behind some thugs from the EDL, and wonder when Amazon are going to deliver the aluminium baseball bat that they’ve ordered.
The right have called for everything from the Army and water cannons, to tougher sentencing and the withdrawal of benefits to eviction from social housing.
The one thing that unites them all is fear. Time for a leader that offers hope, not for some, but for all.
I have an article to read somewhere about how there are no local leaders, which seems a fair point. One of the things fear has done is make people afraid to stand up and be counted – all people. It takes an exceptional person to say ‘follow me, I’m right and I can make life better’ these days. I think a number of factors have led to this situation.
I am also alarmed at the apparently complete acceptance of CCTV cameras now. Pictures from them are released for us all to pore over and modify in Photoshop. I think there is also a wider debate to be had about fear and inaction and the relationship between a mobile society and the media tendency to other large swathes of our populations. Also I was mulling over the post about Norway while I was away and got to wondering what that man meant about ‘feminisation’ anyway, why it was automatically bad and whether all of this comes back to fear of change and some individuals being ill-equipped to cope with it. More mulling required but I would be interested in thoughts on it.
She’s correct, of course. I’m miles away from the riots but I’ve been watching with interest. The press and government seem to be painting it as opportunistic theft (what, just because Cameron was on holiday?) and I’ve seen a fair bit of criticism of the people who went to clear up after some of the riots, I’ve seen a lot of mouthing off all over the place basically, but not so many people *doing* something. We’ve all got opinions, it seems, but people like Camila are pointing out problems and we’re going to need a lot of creative solutions to stop this happening all the time. I don’t know where to start, I really hope more creative people than me are applying themselves to this already.