subscribe: Posts | Comments

Does Facebook ‘condone a culture of rape’?

9 comments

Summary of story from The Huffington Post, August 15, 2011

Feminist and author of ‘The Best of Everything After 50’, Barbara Hannah Grufferman, writes about a Facebook page that has outraged so many of her friends.

This morning, she says she was bombarded with messages from Facebook friends about a Facebook page that has them outraged, and rightly so.

In the last few weeks she’d posted a series of articles focusing on the status of women in America, the Equal Rights Amendment and the ongoing pay inequity between the sexes, all urging women to get mad.

Why? Because anger is often the first step towards action, and action is what this country sorely needs.

All the articles generated a great deal of discussion, which was her intent. But, while most comments were supportive of the points made, some — mostly from men — were negative, taunting, aggressive, and in a few unfortunate cases, vulgar.

Most, of course, felt free to leave their comments directly on Huffington Post, where freedom of speech is alive and well. But, a few — knowing that their choice of words would never pass muster with the moderators — chose, instead, to connect via email.

The venom that spouted from these messages still makes her wince, she continues.

Postings on Facebook and other social media often find themselves in the murky waters between “freedom of speech” and “despicable commentary” and that’s exactly where this page is.

The First Amendment is a right of the American people, the true purpose of which is often misused and abused.

That is the case with this Facebook page (bad grammar and all) — “You know shes playing hard to get when your chasing her down an alleyway.”

To date, it has generated almost 172,000 “likes” and continues to get “likes” and comments even though many people have petitioned Facebook to have it removed.

What can we do? We can start by asking ourselves these questions: Are we, as a society, supporting a war on women by condoning a culture of rape? and What do you think Facebook should do?”

  1. Antje Rook says:

    I reported the Facebook page, and that’s what everybody should do!

  2. Hmmm. Very nervous about banning even this sort of shite.

    Over the last year or so i’ve written up a string of stories about Facebook moderation. Do they, as standard, ban the sort of rubbish we’d like to see banned? er, no.

    F’rinstance, a page (in Serbian) encouragin violence against a gay rights demo in Belgrade survived for weeks, despite dozens of complaints.

    On the other side, anything arty, breasty, anatomical or even vaguely sexual already gets taken down ridiculously fast: that includes pages on breast-feeding, the NY Academy of Art (cause they included naked pics) and a health page helping young men to self-examine for things like prostate and scrotal cancer.

    So-o…i’m not arguing let it be for purist reasons. More the tactical one that, the more you encourage FB to take stuff down, the more likely they will be to take down the good stuff first.

    jane
    xx

    • Doesn’t necessarily follow. 🙂 It isn’t too tricky and to be honest I don’t want to be excusing them by saying ‘oh, we’ve to put up with the nonsense in case they remove some good stuff’.

      Every filter needs to learn what is good and what is bad, Facebook must be constantly adjusting all sorts of things so why shouldn’t this be one of them? Breastfeeding and self-examination for men good; incitement to violence and hate speech bad.

      • Oh, alright then…though i remain nervous. FB are not a very good learning organisation… and when you consider that one of their moderation sites is in India, another in the US, your hopes for getting them to understand simple but progressive ideas as you suggest may be a tad vain.

        But yes: i have complained in the past, particularly where the FB page in question seems to spill out into real action against women, gay groups, etc.

        jane

        • Jane Da Vall says:

          The first amendment does not require anyone to publish anybody’s hate, incitement, propaganda or anything else whatsoever. Facebook make the choice what to publish on their site, let’s encourage them not to choose this.

          The thin end of the wedge, slippery slop, where does it all end argument is for imbeciles.

          • Jane Da Vall says:

            But, and let me be very clear about this, not the kind of imbecile that can’t spell ‘slope’.

        • Even if they do nothing about the page and any objection on the page itself leads to troll pile-on I think it’s important that there is at least a note that not everyone thinks those sorts of pages is hilarious. I believe there are also plenty of messages of protest about innocent pages which happen to feature body parts being censored too. Facebook can’t say they didn’t know, is the main point.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *