subscribe: Posts | Comments

Cervical cancer screened too often, survey finds

0 comments

Summary of story from Reuters, August 18, 2011

Most US doctors screen cervical cancers more than federal guidelines suggest, a study at the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) has found.

The CDC recommends that women are tested every three years, but doctors typically test them annually.

The lead author of the study, Katherine Roland, said: “There’s really no advantage to annual screening compared to screening every two or three years.”

CDC guidelines say women age 30 or older should be testing using a Pap smear and HPV tests. Then, if the results are normal, they should be tested every three years because HPV might take 10 years to progress to the point of cancer.

The American Cancer Society issues the same recommendations, but it says younger women should be tested starting at age 21 or when they become sexually active.

Apparently, as well as the extra costs,  ‘extra’ screening can increases the chance of getting a “false positive” result on a test – meaning the test finds something that turns out not to be cancer.

Women undergoing invasive tests to rule out disease, Roland said, risk “undue harm” from those procedures.

“No test is perfect,” said Philip Castle, an HPV expert at the American Society for Clinical Pathology in Chicago. But “a single negative HPV test is very good at ruling out disease.”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *