subscribe: Posts | Comments

Female action stars too skinny to throw a believable punch

1 comment

Summary of story from New York Magazine, August 25, 2011

In the latest edition of New York Magazine, journalist Kyle Buchanan writes about the difference between male and female action stars and which are more believable.

First up is actress Zoe Saldana, whose role in new action drama Colombiana, he says, is like someone who “resembles a supermodel who could be toppled not just by a gang of thugs but by a stiff breeze.”

While he admits that Saldana is a great actress, a petite woman carrying a huge bazooka and blasting through walls isn’t exactly realistic.

As superhero movies are currently in vogue,  we also see action heroes and heroines racing to comically opposite extremes. As men pack on weight for their Captain America moment, women have to keep the universe in balance by going on the cleanse.

Look no further than The Dark Knight Rises, in which Tom Hardy is bulking up to play the villainous Bane by eating a whole chicken every two hours, while his female counterpart Anne Hathaway describes her Catwoman diet as “dust and dreams.”

Conceptually, it’s also clear why Angeline Jolie gets the green light for action roles. She radiates power and intimidation.

As Lara Croft in Tomb Raider she put on weight in order to look the part,  yet now she has gotten too thin for her punches and kicks to be believably forceful.

Yet there is hope on the horizon – in upcoming action flick ‘Haywire’, Gina Carano a mixed-martial-arts fighter is making her acting debut.

Let it be a lesson to those other actresses who like to talk a good game about getting in shape for acting roles – unless they let us see that essential extra weight on their bodies, it’s just empty calories.

  1. Funnily enough I was talking about just this subject earlier. Nice to know there will be some powerful-appearing women in films as well as the ones who are good at acting it.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *