Warning – discussing problems could make them worse
Project treating US violence from a public health perspective
Woman jailed for shooting ex partner
Summary of story from BBC news, August 26, 2011
A woman who shot her ex-partner after hearing he might have met another woman has been jailed for at least 24 years.
Catherine Hodges, 49, of Norfolk in England, admitted murdering John Loveday at his farm at Stratton Strawless, near Norwich, on 12 June.
Police found 59-year-old Mr Loveday’s body slumped close to a chair in the living room at Botanybay Farm.
Norwich Crown Court heard how Hodges had driven five miles from her home and shot him several times with a rifle.
She was sentenced to life and told she would spend a minimum of 24 years in prison.
















Out of curiousity I had a quick look to see how this sentence compared to other sentences where a male ex-partner has murdered a woman. One received a sentence of thirty years, but a lot more were reported as having killed themselves, or attempted to, after the murder.
No particular point to this, as I said – curiousity. Perhaps someone who knows more about this field has a comment?
As with all media stories this one has been interpreted from a certain perspective. Having talked to Catherine at length about her crime I am aware there is much more to this. Catherine has always accepted her guilt and accepts that she will probably die in jail. However she is also very troubled by aspects of the reporting and the prosecution case. For instance, she has been described as a controlling character. This is based on an inaccurate record made when she reported the shooting to the police. I can honestly say that I’ve never found her to be at all controlling. She is in fact the opposite.
Many women, when under extreme pressure and after many years of abuse, take extreme measures. I’m not excusing what Catherin did. Killing another human being is abhorrent. I just know there is far more to this story than meets the eye.
I know this is a women’s debating forum so apologies for “butting in”.
Catherine is my cousin. Her crime has shocked her close and extended family.
A 24 year minimum term in prison for a 49 year old is a long time and would indicate she will be a sustained threat to society for a very long time. Given this is a crime of passion I find it hard to see the justification to detain her so long as a means of protecting society.
I don’t know all the details of the case – what compelled her to take this drastic action – and what she hoped to achieve. She had the opportunity to take her own life but didn’t – she handed herself in rather than going “on the run”. She was (is probably still) suffering mental illness – and yet I somehow feel that is not an excuse for what she did but a symptom.
As per what Jennifer says, this is probably not quite as black and white as it has been portrayed.