subscribe: Posts | Comments

Holding the baby – childcare costs make working hard for mothers

1 comment

Sarah Cheverton
WVoN co-editor

There’s an all too familiar story reported in today’s Sun about the prohibitive effect of spiralling childcare costs on working mothers .

Childcare costs are actively preventing mothers who want to work from doing so, while the government cuts are simultaneously making large numbers of women redundant from their public sector jobs.

Meanwhile, in the private sector, similar cuts caused by the recession are now having a similar impact.

The loss to the workforce is obvious and immediate. The skills and expertise of mothers who wish to work are lost.

There are also particular implications for women working in certain sectors, as revealed by a recent survey by SSentif .

It showed a rise of 27 per cent in the number of female retail workers, 18 per cent in the number of female care staff and 17 per cent of female cleaning and catering staff now claiming Job Seekers Allowance (JSA) compared to July last year.

Suggestions that these figures may be caused by single mothers being transferred from other benefits onto JSA are refuted by the age bands most affected by cuts, with those most affected aged 40-44 years.

More broadly, the total unemployment rate for women is now the highest it has been since 1988, having increased recently by over 20,000 to 1.05 million.

The overall impact on women is confounded by the continuing lack of women in higher paid and leadership roles in the workplace, with the majority of the cuts hitting low paid and administrative-based jobs in which women are over-represented.

Anna Bird, Acting Chief Executive of the Fawcett Society, which campaigns for the more equitable representation of women in leadership and decision-making positions, is unequivocal in her response to the news of rising female unemployment.

In addition to the impact of the cuts, she said, “at the same time women are facing widening inequality as cuts to public services and benefits bite.”

For those women who manage to keep working despite the prohibitive cost of childcare, the story is no better.

Meet Shonagh and Lee. Shonagh is the manager of a domestic violence reduction service within a local authority, and her partner, Lee, serves in the Royal Marines. They have a baby girl and a 4 year-old boy.

“For my daughter, I’m currently paying £1000 a month in childcare and for my son I pay £400 a month – it’s less for him because I receive a government nursery grant that covers his childcare costs for 15 hours a week,” Shonagh tells me.

“I wasn’t prepared to give up working, my career is really important to me. Lee would be happy to stay at home with the children, and will in the future, but by the time he can leave the Royal Marines, the childcare costs will be significantly less substantial.”

This has a huge impact on their lives.

“The biggest issue for us is having a young family in a tiny house. The costs of childcare means that we can’t afford to move because we can’t afford anywhere bigger. Our house is lovely, but we’re bursting out of the seams!”

Neither is the cost just material.

“Of course, the other thing is that you feel guilty all the time, as a mother, because you’re making that choice to place your children in childcare. ”

“Don’t get me wrong, I made that choice and I’m a better person and a better mum for it! But I pay for that choice through the nose – emotionally as well as financially.”

The answer? Well, for Anna Bird, more women in leadership and decision-making, for a start.

“Decisions that affect us all, be it how to balance the nation’s budget, or our preferred system of welfare, are being made without women round the table…David Cameron must honour his pledge to run a Cabinet where women make up one third of the Ministers.

“In times of economic difficulty it becomes more not less important to have a range of voices and experiences inform government policy,” she said.

The lack of women in leadership roles is a massive issue here. This is not some tokenistic ‘wimminz’ debate about representation – it’s about the economic health of the country in a recession.

We must be able to deploy skilled and capable women in positions at all levels, and to do this we have to address the major barrier that rising childcare costs represent.

As Anna Bird suggests, while women are not involved in decision-making at the highest level, the workplace cannot adapt to their needs.

Nor is the only issue the rising cost of childcare.

The continuing lack of flexible working conditions for working parents and the frankly ridiculous inequality of parenting that supports men’s supremacy in the workplace creates the demand for childcare in the first place and makes sure the hardest impact is felt by women.

The bottom line: something has to give.

I know fathers who want to parent as much as mothers do. (I also know fathers who don’t, but that’s another show). The current working culture and existing organisational structures actively prevent this. Women and men lose out and so do their children.

The lack of women in leadership roles prevents the reorganisation of an outdated workplace from taking place, because the experience of women is lost and the expertise of women is not utilised.

Spiralling female unemployment has the same effect. Our economy and our economic recovery need women working as much as men.

And if we can’t address these simple truths, there’s another one waiting – we all lose.

  1. Shonagh Dillon says:

    Brilliant sarah, very well said x

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *