Guatemalan mother finds lost child: adopted in America
Summary of story from The Guardian, August 30, 2011
Loyda Rodríguez Morales, 26, said that her daughter was kidnapped in 2006.
She and her husband went to the police, put up posters round the neighbourhood and visited orphanages, but without success.
With the help of the human rights group Survivors Foundation, Morales found her daughter on the files of an adoption agency, and listed as being in an orphanage in March 2009.
But she found out too late: according to court records, her daughter Anyelí had left the country the previous year.
The American couple, Timothy and Jennifer Monahan, of Kansas City, Missouri, said that they legally adopted the girl, now known as Karen Abigal Monahan, in 2008.
After a lengthy fight by Morales, a Guatemalan court has ordered that Anyelí Liseth Hernández Rodríguez should be returned to the country.
The situation poses a dilemma for the US government, caught between its international legal obligations to comply with the Guatemalan court order and its concern for the American couple and the child, who is now a US citizen.
















This is a critical issue for women with children. Is it right for a woman whose child has been stolen, who searched for more than two years fighting to find her child, who pleaded two years with a selfish couple to return her child, who finally won a court case that proved the child was hers . . . is it right for such a woman to be told: “Sorry, too late. You should forget your child and let the traffickers have their way.”
Dr. Timothy and Jennifer Monahan of Liberty, Missouri, knew early on that they were dealing with shady people when they went to adopt a child far from home. Two of the lawyers they hired are now in prison charged with conspiracy and child trafficking. They have turned to the Washington, DC, lobbying and media spin company, Peter Mirijanian Public Affairs, to put pressure on the government and the public to have it their way.
The Monahans have the the subject of a two year investigation into child trafficking. Still they are unwilling to come forth and return the stolen child to her mother. Everyday the Monahans continue to keep a child from her mother and family is an act of cruelty. Perhaps being an orthopedic surgeon and living in a big house in a wealthy neighborhood protects people from being prosecuted for crimes, even the worst of the worse crimes.
This case is also about thousands of children illicitly placed into child trafficking through adoption. It is necessary to stop this trade in children and prosecute the wrongdoers. The Monahan’s congressman Sam Graves and Senator Mary Landrieu are involved along with our government. Guatemala has taken steps to stop child trafficking through adoption and prosecute those who participated. Will the US do the same?
For this stolen chil, Anyeli (aka Karen Abagail Monahan), and so many children sold to adoption, the Monahans deserve their day in court to have the truth of their actions revealed. First this child should be allowed to go home to the mother who loves her.
I agree with your post. If the Monahans are grieved that a child they bought turned out to have a family elsewhere would it not be better for them to turn their grief into action, to help ensure this does not happen again in future?