subscribe: Posts | Comments

WH Smith and references to ‘women’s fiction’ Part 2

0 comments

Summary of story from The Observer, September 4, 2011

Following a direct appeal by two female customers (see WVoN story), WH Smith CEO Kate Swann has agreed to remove all reference to ‘women’s fiction’ at points of sale from next month.

Claire Leigh and Julia Gillick, both 29 and from Tonbridge, in Kent, were delighted with Ms Swann’s timely response to their letter, in which they had complained that the ‘women’s fiction’ section in question was ‘light, with pink fluffiness, with no classic authors.’

Gillick, an English teacher, is encouraging her pupils to write to supermarkets to ask them to remove similar section labels.

Writer Viv Groskop makes two points.

Firstly, that this is an uplifting people-power tale that will make female authors cheer.

Second, that it’s good to see the youthful feminist chapter of middle England is thriving.

She also points out that it would be ridiculous to see a sign for ‘men’s fiction’, which would feature any man who has ever written a novel, ranging from Dickens to Parsons.

She then says that ‘women’s fiction’ is a genuine market, being shorthand for commercial fiction by women, for women, with women buying 80 per cent of the fiction sold.

The real question therefore is marketing. Readers, she says, love labels, seeing chick-lit as a handy indicator of ‘stuff I like,’ an anathema, she says, to writers.

And publishing is driven by sales – Sophie Kinsella’s Mini Shopaholic sells thousands in a week – more than Booker shortlisted The Sense of an Ending by Julian Barnes could hope to see in a month.

Groskop concludes that while it’s good to challenge ‘reductive’ labels, one cannot doubt the power of marketing.

And she doubts that Julian Barnes would sniff at selling three times more copies and suggests vajazzling his next book jacket as a test.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *