subscribe: Posts | Comments

Mississippi to vote on reversing abortion rights by redefining ‘person’

3 comments

Summary of story from the Guardian, September 9, 2011

Mississippi voters will be allowed to vote on an initiative that seeks to reverse abortion rights by redefining the term “person” to apply at the moment of conception.

The state’s supreme court refused to block the amendment, which will now appear on the general election ballot on November 8.

A majority of the justices said they could not rule on whether measures were constitutional until voters of the legislature had had a chance to pass them.

Civil rights campaigners criticised the court ruling and described the measure, known as measure 26, as “harmful to women”.

Bear Atwood, legal director of the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) of Mississippi, said: “This initiative is extreme and could severely undermine women’s access to birth control, in vitro fertilization and life-saving medical procedures.”

Measure 26 seeks to alter the term person or persons to include: “every human being from the moment of fertilisation, cloning or functional equivalent thereof”.

It is part of a swing across conservative states, particularly in the south, towards legislating for life to begin at conception, thus undermining piecemeal Roe v Wade, the landmark US supreme court ruling that set out the right to abortion.

The initiative was challenged by a Mississippi citizen because it failed to comply with the state’s official ballot initiative process which forbids making modifications to the Bill of Rights.

Cristen Hemmins, the plaintiff, said: “As a lifelong Mississippian, I am disappointed that this broad and intrusive measure has been allowed on the ballot.

“I call on all voters to vote ‘no’ on #26. The government should not be interfering with the personal and private health care decisions of Mississippi families.”

But anti-abortion groups such as the American Family Association and Pro-Life Mississippi welcomed the judge’s decision.

The ruling follows that three months ago, when Rennie Gibbs, of Mississippi, became the first woman to be charged with murder following the stillbirth of her baby (see WVoN story).

  1. Further privileging the personhood of a collection of cells above the personhood of the fully-functioning adult woman carrying said cells… I don’t understand the sorts of people who seriously suggest these kinds of laws.

  2. vicki wharton says:

    I think it shows a hierarchy where women’s human rights come below those of men, children and now cells forming into human beings. What next – favouring the rights of a potato over women or locking them up for eating a living vegetable? Until a foetus is able to live independently of the woman carrying it I think its rights have to come second to the host. Possibly a simplistic approach and I would prefer a world without abortion, but I would prefer a world where every father stood by his unborn child too and I don’t see men being locked up for abandoning a woman he has made pregnant. Until that day, if a woman is left solely responsible for the pregnancy, then she should have sole responsibility as to whether she chooses to continue it.

    • There are already attempts to privilege hypothetical bundles of cells over adult women, look at all that ‘pre-pregnancy’ nonsense. Another excuse to regulate the lives of women according to the whims of some prudish group.

      It is a dangerous road to travel – what other bundles of cells will be privileged next? Will we need prosecuting because we wilfully destroyed brain cells, or liver cells, or anything else? Until a foetus can live and breathe on its own then surely its right to exist does not come before an adult’s right to exist?

      Another infuriating aspect of this sort of campaign is that the self-righteous don’t seem to be shouting so loudly for children’s services, for affordable childcare, good education, access to health services and good food, safe neighbourhoods for all these children, support for parents who are struggling with other life issues… the list goes on. No, they just want to have a say in what women they don’t even know do with their own bodies.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *