subscribe: Posts | Comments

Breastfeeding women more aggressive?

3 comments

Summary of story from CBS News.com, September 9, 2011

Girl power? Maybe it should be grrrrl power, at least when it comes to mothers who breast-feed their babies.

Nursing moms protect their babies twice as aggressively as their bottle-feeding counterparts, according to a provocative new study.

“Breast-feeding mothers aren’t going to go out and get into bar fights, but if someone is threatening them or their infant, our research suggests they may be more likely to defend themselves in an aggressive manner,” study author Dr Jennifer Hahn-Holbrook, a UCLA psychologist, said in a written statement.

The study suggests that the act of nursing blunts women’s physiological reaction to perceived threats, tamping down fear and giving them extra courage to defend themselves and their babies.

For the study – published in the September issue of Psychological Science – researchers recruited three groups of women: 18 nursing mothers, 17 moms who used formula to feed their infants, and 20 non-mothers.

As her baby was taken care of nearby, each woman was pitted against an overtly rude research assistant in a series of computerized time-reaction contests – and encouraged to celebrate each victory by pushing a button to deliver a sound blast.

What happened? The blasts delivered by the breast-feeding moms were twice as loud and as long as those given by non-mothers and nearly twice as loud as long as those given by bottle-feeding moms. The researchers viewed the bigger blasts as a sign of aggression.

And measurements of the moms’ blood pressure showed that breast-feeders had pressures significantly lower than those of bottle-feeders or non-mothers. Lower blood pressure suggests reduced anxiety.

The so-called “lactation aggression” phenomenon has been identified in rats, mice, lions, deer, sheep, and other non-human mammals, Dr Hahn-Holbrook said. But she believed hers was the first study to demonstrate the phenomenon in humans.

WVoN Comment: Hmmm. Not sure that the ability to push a button for longer than the other women in the study is demonstrating that women who breast feed would defend their children more aggressively than those who bottle fed their babies. Also, does this mean the women without children in the study wouldn’t bother to defend a baby?  I have to assume that this is a typical case of a mainstream media report of a complicated research study and so it has missed the point completely: otherwise the findings are stupid.

  1. @abalanophage says:

    This is why psychology isn’t a science, no matter what they call their journals. Not only is it a leap of faith to assume longer button push=aggression (it could as easily be poorer co-ordination or slower reaction time) – more importantly, 55 of anything isn’t a statistically relevant sample size, and only a non-scientist would think it was. Even most psychologists manage to design better studies than this.

  2. Even if pushing a button demonstrated more aggression, could it possibly be that in our culture, breastfeeding a baby takes a level of determination and assertiveness that is so great, that it rubs off into other area of life? It may be that breastfeeding per se doesn’t make mothers more assertive, but that if you’ve managed to get through the constant undermining and sneering that breastfeeding a baby earns you, you are pretty damned assertive by that stage because you’ve had to be.

  3. Jane Osmond says:

    Jenny: yes, very good point. 🙂

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *