subscribe: Posts | Comments

Accused mother faces legal system educated to the dangers of postpartum depression

1 comment

Summary of Story from The LA Times, September 11, 2011

Legal experts say that Sonia Hermosillo, accused of the murder of her seven-month-old son, will encounter a legal system more aware of postpartum psychosis than it was a decade ago.

She was too distraught and unresponsive to enter a plea in court a week after Noe fell or was thrown to his death from the fourth floor of a parking garage in Orange County, California.

Medical and legal analysts predict that if she pursues an insanity defence, she will encounter judges and jurors that are more likely to see her as a victim of mental illness rather than a premeditated killer.

Prosecutors are seeking a murder conviction and say that the removal of a helmet worn by the baby to correct a skull deformity suggests that she did know what she was doing.

According to Melissa Murray, a professor in family and criminal law, said she found 18 cases in which women charged with murdering their children asserted a defense of temporary insanity because of postpartum psychosis.

About half the women were acquitted and committed to mental institutions for treatment, she said.

Mild postpartum depression affects about 80 per cent of new mothers for a few days or weeks and about one in 1,000 new mothers suffers from the most severe form of the illness.

Sharps falls in estrogen and progesterone after childbirth are thought to be a trigger and severe illness is much more likely in women with a history of psychiatric illness.

  1. Jane Osmond says:

    This is a sad story – no mother in her right mind would do this. She is obviously mentally ill.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *