subscribe: Posts | Comments

T-shirt misogyny, the new masculinity

6 comments

Simon King
WVoN co-editor

“Clothes make the man”, said Mark Twain.

For many of us, the messages transmitted by a stranger’s clothing are the first, and sometimes only, part of our communication with them.

T-shirt slogans have become a way of identifying ourselves, of expressing our ideas covertly to see if we and our beliefs are acceptable in a particular social environment.

When someone recognises and empathises with the message that we transmit we feel as if our opinion has been validated, we feel part of a group.

So it’s hardly surprising that one of the main uses of t-shirts is to transmit and discuss masculinity.

One hundred years ago it was easy to identify what masculinity meant. Privilege, power and responsibility.

With the 20th century those definitions no longer applied and while feminist theory allowed women to explore and develop their identities, men seemed to retreat into silence.

Masculinity found itself lost in a void of communication where a fear of male on male ridicule, and an unwillingness to admit that old definitions no longer applied, ensured that an open discussion of identity did not take place.

The discussion took place on the front of our clothes instead.

“Dear God, thanks for beer, women and football. Keep up the good work”, “It’s not a beer belly it’s a fuel tank for a sex machine”, “I didn’t ask you to dance, I said you look fat in those pants”, “Porn, it’s cheaper than dating”, “I need a hug but I’ll settle for a blowjob”, “Sometimes being a bitch is all a woman has to hold onto”.

Yes these t-shirts are offensive. They’re meant to be. The puerile, misogynistic messages engrained in them have been created to serve two purposes:

The first is to cause women to rail against the messages in the hope that the masculinity of the wearer will be reinforced by female conflict.

The second is to encourage an approving male reaction that will help to underscore the statement as correct and strengthen the definition of masculinity that it advocates.

As these sexist messages become increasingly prevalent in everyday life, T-shirt slogans become the closest thing that many males have to a codex on masculinity.

That’s dangerous. The messages on these t-shirts are in effect, pathetic. They signify men who are lonely, incapable of having romantic relationships or even communicating.

They speak of a weak and broken masculinity that has nothing left to hold onto with the exception of vitriol and misogyny.

Witness the effects of this new t-shirt masculinity in the anonymous pages that appear on Facebook with titles like “Throwing bricks at sluts”.

These pages, the natural extension of t-shirt slogans, are places where like-minded individuals can show their support and validate misogyny to the point where the definition of masculine is someone who is violent towards and oppresses women.

Unwillingness on behalf of Facebook to limit the spread of these messages, and negligence on behalf of t-shirt designers in promoting them, presents a threat both to young men whose ideas of masculinity have been deformed and the women who have to face them.

Negative attitudes towards women’s rights, rape and domestic violence that are so frequently heard in discussions such as those in the Guardian’s CiF threads, undoubtedly have some of their roots in the language of t-shirts.

So these slogans need to stop. These t-shirts manufacturers need to stop and it is long past time that websites stepped in to monitor the messages that they are transmitting.

The men’s clothing store Topman recently withdrew two sexist t-shirts after complaints about the messages on them (see WVoN story).

A look at the t-shirt selection sold by both Topman and fellow male clothing retailer Burton reveals t-shirts focused on images of industrial towns, American iconography and the Rolling Stones.

Yes there are sexualised images of women mixed in there and yes there are also t-shirts for the “Ultimate Man” with “Equipment size: Large”, but they are not the dominant messages.

Major retailers are, I believe, becoming a little more aware, a little more conscious of the messages that they are distributing with regards to masculinity.

There is power in the messages that we put on our t-shirts. Topman’s removal of sale signified that. If the power did not exist there would have been no need to remove them.

Perhaps now it is time for them to take responsibility for educating and shaping men so as to stem the tide of pathetic men who find that misogyny is the only thing they can hold onto.

  1. Heather Kennedy says:

    Great article Simon and really interesting hear a man’s perspective. You’re totally on the money with the link between facebook pages and offensive T shirts. Almost as insulting to men are they are to women.

  2. I agree with the article and Heather’s comment. I wonder if the same sort of thing happens with questions of nationality? I’ve seen discussions about what it means to be English (observed as an outsider – I’m not English myself) and increasingly it seems to be defined as ‘not like [whatever group]’. It speaks of a lack somewhere, defining yourself by trying to ensure that some other group which is emphatically *not* yours doesn’t thrive or prosper.

    In the article, Simon, you mention “One hundred years ago it was easy to identify what masculinity meant. Privilege, power and responsibility” which sort of suggests that men have none of these things now because feminism pointed out that there is nothing exclusively male about any of those things. Actually, not even that – the suggestion is that there has been a century-long existential crisis amongst males simply because it was pointed out! I suppose we keep on pointing out that feminism is still not about taking things away but about sharing them out so we *all* have power and responsibility. Not sure if we can all have privilege, equality would be better.

  3. Great article Simon, very thought provoking. I think that men, as much as women, are at risk from the negatives of gender stereotyping in our society and from the human desire to pigeon hole one another (and ourselves).

    The fashion and media markets are forever foisting the ‘ideal’ image of ‘male’ or ‘female’ on us. Generally we sympathise more with women, because it’s a more obvious and direct message for them. But there’s definitely one in there for men and I know so, so many men that feel not only uncomfortable about it, but downright threatened.

    What does it mean to be a man? In times when women are ever more assertive, where does the modern man sit? What is their role? Are there roles any more? It’s little wonder that some, confronted by this confusion, have bristled and gone on the offensive.

    It’s good to see a backlash to these misogynistic slogans, facebook pages and forums, that shops are removing t-shirts, and great to see that it’s not only women fighting back.

    I think we would all do well to remember that sexism isn’t just ‘anti-woman’ and equality isn’t just about ‘women’s rights’. We all suffer from an imbalance, even if it’s not that obvious at the start.

    • Jem, you’ve illustrated what I was trying to get at – why, if women are more assertive, should it mean that men are less so? As far as I know it is not an either/or thing. Why have women not suffered this lack of definition because our roles are not so defined any more either?

      • I don’t think women being more assertive means men are less so. I think Simon’s point was almost that they feel the need to assert themselves more (hence the attention grabbing slogans) perhaps? As to why should it? Well, I don’t believe it has to be that way.

        I also think in some ways women have suffered a loss of definition. But I think it manifests differently for us. Much of what we’re doing is spreading into other roles, those not traditionally thought of as ‘female’ etc. So rather than feel our role to be restricted, our problem is one of excessive choice. Who are we? What defines us? This is a very significant issue of the ‘post modern’ society. In much the same way as the (claimed) loss of the class system has provided both opportunities and dissatisfaction.

        Of course, I don’t think it’s as simple as that, but that’s a starting point I guess?

        • Good point on the assertiveness – I wonder if and why that’s the case?

          Yes, that’s a good starting point. I also wonder if some feminists (out there in the blogosphere) cluster in groups because ‘feminist’ is an identity and role that has edges, instead of being the career woman, fulfilled person, good mother, in charge of the household, drop-dead-gorgeous, accepting, understanding and well-rounded person we’re told we should be! 😀 It’s a lot to take on. 😉

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *