United States police accused of systematically mishandling and ignoring rape cases
Womensenews.org reports on the systematic mishandling and shelving of rape cases by the police across the United States. Rape cases are increasingly being deemed not worthy of investigation, and the out of date definition of ‘rape’ used by police results in an severe under-counting of these crimes. Only ‘forcible rape’ is counted, with other forced sexual acts falling outside this remit. Eleanor Smeal from the Feminist Majority Foundation in Arlington, Virginia, says that these exclusions create the impression that rape is a much smaller problem than it really is, and results in under-funding and under-resourcing.
Sarah Reedy’s experience is symptomatic of this. Whilst working at a Cranberry Gulf Station in 2004, 19 year old Reedy was held at gunpoint by a male, who robbed the cash register and forced Reedy to perform oral sex. The investigating detective, Frank Evanson, didn’t believe her story – instead, Reedy was accused of stealing the money herself and was later jailed for five days, all while she was four months pregnant.
This mirrors problems across the United States. Senator Al Franklin of Minnesota voiced concerns that some police departments bill victims for rape kits that can be used as criminal evidence, and expect them to seek a reimbursement. The Baltimore Sun found that the number of rape cases reported had declined by 80% since 1992, while the percentage of rape cases classified as ‘unfounded’ , or not worthy of investigation, had tripled.
Carol Tracy, executive director of the Women’s Law Project, a rights group in Philadelphia, has said: “Thousands of sexual assault cases – almost one third of all reports from the mid-1980s through 1998 – were buried in a non-crime code. The victims were never advised that their complaints had been shelved.”












