Minnesota terror case: only a fraction of recordings played, say defence
Summary of story from ABC News, October 14, 2011
Only a fraction of conversations from hundreds of hours of recorded phone calls were played in the prosecution of two Minnesota women, according to a defence attorney.
The attorney, who represents one of the two women accused of routing money and fighters to Somalian terrorist group al-Shabab, suggested that the prosecution only presented statements which could support their case.
It was revealed last week that Amina Farah Ali, 35, and Hawo Mohamed Hassan, 64, have been under investigation by the FBI since 2008 (see WVoN story).
During cross-examination on Thursday, Ali’s attorney, Dan Scott, noted that in one recording jurors heard only 41 seconds of a 20 minute call. Another was shortened from 19 minutes to five.
The recorded calls are in Somali, and jurors are following along with written transcripts translated into English. Only the conversations selected by the prosecutors have been translated.
Prosecutors have played excerpts from nearly 100 phone calls recorded during a 10 month wiretap on Ali’s home and mobile phone.
In the recordings, the women talk about jihad, seek pledges from participants in religious teleconferences, and talk about arranging to send money abroad. References to “the enemy” are an allusion to the FBI, according to one special agent serving as a witness.
However, local Somalis following the case said that only playing selections of the recordings was unfair, as it is impossible to contextualise what the women were saying.
Investigators also searched Ali’s bins and computer, finding photographs of fighters and notebooks containing contact details of people alleged to have participated in teleconferences.
However, Scott said that the photographs had been found in temporary Internet files, meaning they had not been saved or uploaded.
Ali and Hassan, who are US citizens of Somali descent, are among 20 people charged in Minnesota’s federal investigation into recruitment and financing for al-Shabab.
The women claim that they were raising money for charity. According to Hassan’s attorney, she didn’t know her activities were illegal.











