On the ‘Queen Bee syndrome’ and pure merit
A non-executive director of the Royal Bank of Scotland, Baroness Sheila Noakes, recently took part in what writer Margareta Pagano called ‘the most extraordinary interview’ on the BBC’s Today radio programme.
The Baroness said the fixation on quotas for women on boards was silly, and that even a board of 20 men could be considered a balanced one, provided that the men think differently.
But masses of research shows that having more women on boards improves productivity and overall performance of companies.
There is one fascinating and in our – and here I mean feminist – case sick element of the ‘women on the board’ debate.
It’s the “only woman in the room syndrome”. It dominates so many of the UK’s boardrooms and rather too much daily life.
It’s the one where one female director seems to quite like being the queen bee and doesn’t want other women around.
And you have to wonder if one of the reasons that David Cameron is so resistant to fixed quotas is that he is listening to too many “only woman in the room” types.
Another argument against quotas is the claim that they create tokenism – that the women are there for show alone.
But surely if all the compelling arguments dictate that company performance does increase with more women on boards, then that can’t be true.
And it is rather inferring that all the men on any one board are there on merit alone, which is also disputable.

















The problem is that it’s easy for those that are benefitting from the current system to see qoutas as saying “we don’t think that you are entitled to your position and we think you are discriminating”.
So I think that arguments about qoutas being discriminating or about tokenism is a diversion. A way to not have to look yourself in the mirror, or simply a way to not accept the question being asked at all.
While we may not have anything to hide, we don’t want scrutiny. We don’t want to be a suspect by default.