Inquiry into benefits of UK’s breast cancer screening announced
Summary of story from The Guardian, October 26, 2011
An independent inquiry into breast cancer screening in the UK has been set up amid controversy around its benefits and possible dangers (see WVoN story).
The UK government’s cancer chief Professor Sir Mike Richard announced the decision to hold an enquiry in an open letter in the British Medical Journal to the professor of complex obstetrics at King’s College London, Susan Bewley.
Ms Bewley had written to him with her concerns over routine screening.
She had said although there is a history of breast cancer in her family she will not have a National Health Service (NHS) breast cancer screening because the programme ‘did not tell the whole truth’.
She supports criticism from a number of scientists who say the NHS screening programme wrongly identifies cancers that might never harm women, leading to unnecessary and potentially damaging treatment with surgery, drugs and radiation therapy.
They also contest the official NHS position, which is that although there is some over-treatment as a result of screening, mammograms save lives.
Professor Bewley said journals showed that a reputable and growing body of international opinion acknowledged breast cancer screening was not as good as used to be thought.
“The distress of over-diagnosis and decision-making when finding lesions that might (or might not) be cancer that might (or might not) require mutilating surgery is increasingly being exposed.”
“The oft-repeated statement that ‘1,400 lives a year are saved’ has not been subjected to proper scrutiny. Even cancer charities use lower estimates,” she wrote to Professor Richard.
She said the big change is that the NHS is now much better at treatment.
“In the past few years millions of women passing through the breast screening treadmill have been unaware of the problems, criticism and real numerical risks they face,” she said.
“Should the independent review conclude that the balance of harms outweighs the benefits of breast screening, I will have no hesitation in referring the findings to the UK national screening committee and then ministers,” said Professor Sir Mike Richard.











