subscribe: Posts | Comments

British banks discriminating against women, report claims

3 comments

Summary from the Daily Mail, November 11, 2011

Banks in the US, UK and Europe are denying women mortgages and loans on the basis of their gender, a think-tank claims.

A research paper by the Institute of Public Policy Research alleges that banks are discriminating against women, particularly pregnant women or new mothers, when applying for loans.

It also claims female business owners can expect to pay higher interest rates than men. Bank officials are said to treat women as inherently less able to understand how to set up and run a business than men.

The report’s author, Cambridge professor Noreena Hertz, said:

“It’s as if we’ve gone back in time to the 1950s. Banks need to be put on notice that such behaviour is both unlawful and unacceptable.”

Hertz has called for banks to publish their lending decisions by gender.

The UK’s Deputy Prime Minister, Nick Clegg, has passed the issue to equalities minister Lynne Featherstone to assess the extent of the problem.

The British Bankers Association rejected the allegations.

  1. Wouldn’t a lot of this make sense though? If you take the new mother / pregnant woman case it is likely that their income will drop in the next 9-12 months making them a riskier investment than someone childless / not pregnant (simply due to maternity leave). Similarly a not-insignificant number of women do have multiple children in a short period of time (reduced capacity to earn) and some do leave work after this period. While this might not affect their ability to repay it surely must be taken into consideration (and you can’t take into account say their partner working full-time if it is an individual loan and only to a reduced level if it is a join one).

    In that case this wouldn’t strictly be a gender based assessment but one of risk amongst ‘people who are / have recently been pregnant’ which unfortunately includes only women and certain other genders.

    • Jane Da Vall says:

      I like the ‘certain other genders’. This won’t do, though, 2ndnin. Firstly, it ‘making sense’ to you is no substitute for it actually being a fact demonstrated by research. Absent data, this is just plain old discrimination.

      Secondly, women are, probably, always going to be the ones having children. Childbirth being necessary for the good of us all, it is not fair that women are penalised in every area of life, finance, jobs, health, education, because of it. This is the current situation and it is wrong. Women must begin to exercise their political power collectively and force change.

      • Jane, I included that since there isn’t a binary gender but rather male, female, a variety of intersex and gender-sex dimorphisms that mean it’s not strictly women that can become pregnant.

        If you prefer rather than ‘making sense’:
        Gender pay gap studies show that maternity affects women’s earning potential negatively.
        UK laws give pregnant / formerly pregnant people maternity leave with a duration higher than paternity leave however with reduced earnings for this period.
        Significant numbers of women tend to take part of this leave.

        Three factors that mean it does make sense that they are considered less financially able, the ball would be in the other party’s court to prove that they don’t meet those conditions.

        I would question how women are penalised in education and health because of childbirth, I haven’t seen any research to that end. Jobs wise of course they are penalised when they don’t conform to the standard working pattern (which is yes a single earner / stay at home partner offering support at current). Comparing the working patterns of child bearing women to people with a similar absence pattern shows they aren’t discriminated against for being pregnant but rather for breaking the standard working patterns (I can’t remember the studies for that one but it was an interesting read).

        So what is the ideal situation? How do we map working against parenthood (and non-parenthood), how do we make it work fairly for everyone?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *