subscribe: Posts | Comments

Police officer reinstated despite violence against woman

1 comment

Summary of story from BBC News Wiltshire, December 2, 2011

A UK police officer who was sacked after being jailed for throwing a woman on to a concrete cell floor has won his job back.

Sgt Mark Andrews was dismissed by Wiltshire Police after being seen on CCTV in July 2008 dragging Pamela Somerville, 60, across the floor.

He was dismissed in January but the decision has been overturned on appeal and he must now be reinstated.

Wiltshire Police said it was “surprised and disappointed” by the ruling.

The police force and Wiltshire Police Authority are now considering whether to appeal against the decision by the independent Police Appeals Tribunal.

The ruling indicates Mr Andrews can be reinstated to his former rank with immediate effect.

In September 2010 Sgt Andrews was found guilty of causing Ms Somerville actual bodily harm and was jailed for six months (see WVoN story).

He spent six days in prison, but was released on bail pending an appeal at Oxford Crown Court, which he later won in November 2010.

His conviction was subsequently quashed after the appeal judge felt satisfied Sgt Andrews did not intend to throw Ms Somerville into the cell.

Mr Justice Bean concluded the injuries she suffered “were probably caused by her falling to the floor after letting go of the door frame”.

Ms Somerville was arrested after she was found asleep in her car near her home and detained for failing to provide a sample for a breath test.

She denied any wrongdoing and the charges against her were later dropped due to insufficient evidence.

WVoN comment: Ms Somerville’s comment in September on the original sentence says it all:

Basically the man’s a bully and there is a reason the police have prosecuted him.

The sentence he receives should equate to the fact the British public need to know the police will not treat you as if you were in a war-torn third world country

  1. vicki wharton says:

    I think the fact that he felt ok to assault the woman in his custody in the first place and is then reinstated shows the level of institutional sexism in this country. I noticed it myself when I took a man to court who had deliberately rammed my car with his when I was in the middle of parking and therefore blocking his way. Not only did the district judges allow him to quote heresay, demean the independent witness who had appeared on my behalf and intimidate me by not allowing me to answer his questions when he cross examined me, but bent over backwards to help him with his case whilst dismissing my experience of trauma as a victim as ‘irrelevant’. Same when I was a victim of sexist violence from my ex partner. The police and social services treated me as a co perpetrator of violence on my daughter rather than a victim of his violence which I was just defending myself from. There’s been a real sea change in the recognition of sexism as a discrimination that is alive and well and thriving in a culture of laddism.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *